City Cellar Wine Bar & Grill - Westbury
NIce setting, attentive staff, prompt service, great food.
The waitress was fine but the entrée came a little late. My brick checken was very dry and hard to chew. My wife order of the shrimp and scallops was very lite. Two little shrimp and scallops mostly corn rossoto. I really try to like the place but hard to get over the poor food.
Everything was close to perfect from the moment we walked it, with the exception I found it a little chilly, but that was just me. When the food was delivered, I happened to be indisposed. The server asked if I wanted it sent back to be reheated. I never had this service before from anyplace.
It was quite chilly that night on Long Island, so the restaurant was not that crowded.
Nice table away from others and good food and drink
Service was excellent! If I could remember our servers name, I’d write here in CAPS!
Perfect lunch venue!
Extensive wine list and lunch menu. Also speciality drinks are the best!!!
Service cannot be beat!
We haven't been to City Cellar in a long time. We returned last night for an exceptional LI Restaurant Week menu. The entire meal was excellent and the service spectacular.
Thanks so much for a lovely date night.
I ordered the sea scallop dinner, I was very disappointed when I receiver 2 scallops and 4 peices of over cooked shrimp
It was okay. Was nice to say I have been there once, sure. Would I go again? No. The atmosphere was spot on for a date night. The food, mediocre. Value per dollar is simply not there. The staff was pretty friendly.
A fantastic and wonderful place. Highly recommend! Run…don’t walk because the food and service is outstanding!!!
Loved our time..food Tuna tartare,Grilled Octopus Appetizers wonderful..Jazz band perfect..a definite must..Pitcher of Blackberry Sangria..oh yes..perfectly made Scallops/Shrimp Risotto, Seared tuna a must to have!Best was our Waitress....smiles and A1 personality..Thanks for our time together ❤️
Food was excellent. We each had a fish entree. Tuna, striped bass and salmon were delicious. Gabby our server was outstanding!
Nice place. Excellent waitress. Sat us quickly on a Saturday night. Food just not that good.
Celebrated my husbands birthday and brought my granddaughter for the celebration. Food was amazing. Love every meal we have eaten here when there is a special occasion.
The service was excellent and the ambiance was cozy and delightful.
Went to have dinner for my birthday. We didn’t know what to expect. We
Great brunch and great service!
Had a lovely time. Very nice restaurant with great customer service. I felt that the wine was extremely overpriced while some of the menu options were reasonable. Our server was lovely and very knowledgeable. Happy I tried this restaurant but next time I will look very closely at wine prices.
Good gathering place. Went for brunch with friends. Waitress was at our table minimally. Couldn’t order a second drink. Food was good but cold. Unfortunately they need more staff.
Delightful restaurant & experience. Food was excellent, waitress, Jennifer was very attentive.
Delicious, elegant. Highly recommend! We love the unique menu!
Aleays a great dining experience! We totally recommend it!
There were a lot of fruit flies and they ended up in our food. But the food was great and they were accommodating of allergies. I suggest doing take out
Start to finish a great experience. Will be back!
Our Server was great. Glad to see the place was not packed as I was concerned about covid. Surprised that LI doesn't check vaccine cards + ID.
Our server Seth was amazing!!!!
Great time! We will definitely be returning!
I have been eating at city cellar for years, and although it is just as pleasant, prices are higher sand the value is less.
Our server, Courtney, was excellent. She made the whole meal very enjoyable.
I use to love this place but unfortunately the last 2 times I came here I was a little disappointed. The table the hostess sat me at had crumbs everywhere including the floor. I could not step without feeling all the crumbs. When they switched me to another area that table wobbled and the silverware had some food stains.
My friend and I decided to just go to the bar instead, and it was much better.
Although the bartender was very talented and somewhat friendly, he had some attitude when my friend inquired about the pour of wine. Actually, the bartender seemed annoyed with any question that could not be answered with yes or no. Perhaps because he was the only one back there and had to do bar and table orders. But overall, he did a great job.
Speaking of table orders, a few waiters were handling the drinks and using their hands to scoop out olives and the like. This is a big no no.
I will consider giving this place another chance because it was very classy and catered well to their patrons in the past. Perhaps with everything going on things are a bit off. I probably will revisit months from now and I hope by then things go back to how they use to be. It is a beautiful place at a convenient location.
Always consistent. Always a lovely and delicious meal.
Great place to go, I recommend it. Good food, good ambiance.
Fabulous place to meet up with friends. Very friendly staff, excellent waiter & waitresses. Good is always delicious.
Had a great time hear. The service was as expected which was good. The menu’s font was a little too small to read and the lighting didn’t help.
Had a business dinner here and it was great. It’s what you would expect from an upscale restaurant.
After our bread and wine arrived, fruit flies or gnats started flying by our table. By the time we were eating our meal, the bread was covered in no less than 10 fruit flies. I didn’t see any bugs in our food (and I prefer to think there weren’t any inside) but the infestation of flies is concerning. I hope this gets fixed because it’s a beautiful restaurant with delicious food.
Four of my girlfriends went to brunch to celebrate a birthday and the food was absolutely delicious. The service was great and we had an amazing time.
I would have rated it higher if restrooms were more clean. It was very dirty but they did clean it after I used it.
Very dissappointed - We always loved coming here for lunch. There uesed to be a lunch special for $19.95 pre pandemic. Now the same lunch is $35.00 - RIDICULUS TO SPEND $80 FOR LUNCH. Food wasn't that good either. WE had a tuna salad and the tuna was funky. Told the waiter and he didnt adjust the check.
They also used to have a lunch club tyhat has been discontinued.
I will be looking for a different lunch place.
Food was enjoyable but not good enough to warrant price. The service was ok and atmosphere was nice.
You can order delivery directly from City Cellar Wine Bar & Grill - Westbury using the Order Online button.
City Cellar Wine Bar & Grill - Westbury is rated 4.4 stars by 2949 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.