Best Italian Restaurants in Puyallup

Price: Moderate (23)Price: Expensive (6)Price: Very Expensive (2)

5 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Toscanos Italian Grill restaurant

1. Toscanos Italian Grill

4.6

Exceptional(469)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Puyallup

Booked 8 times today

Toscanos Italian Grill is highly reputed for its unique and excellent Italian cuisine. The restaurant offers an extensive menu, including a remarkable wine list which features both local and Italian wines, and a dessert menu that pays homage to traditional Italian aperitifs and delights. Reviewers consistently praise the restaurant’s excellent food, great ambiance, and attentive service. Particularly celebrated are the spicy short rib pasta, the watermelon panzanella salad, chicken piccatta, and creme brulee. Many guests have highlighted that the food is not standard Italian, but rather "uniquely Toscano's Italian," an authentic experience that rivals dining in Italy itself.

A photo of Mama Stortini's - Puyallup restaurant

2. Mama Stortini's - Puyallup

4.6

Exceptional(1089)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Puyallup

Booked 9 times today

Mama Stortini's in Puyallup is a haven of superb American cuisine that consistently delights its patrons. As indicated by numerous reviews, both the food and service have elicited high praise, resulting in an excellent dining experience. Customers have lauded the restaurant's caring approach to catering for individuals with food allergies, noting the staff's knowledge and attentiveness. The establishment's ability to handle large parties and special events, maintaining high standards in food and service, is another highlight. The unique and delicious food, ranging from amazing Italian dishes to the best spumoni ice cream around, further underscores its quality. With great reviews and high customer satisfaction, Mama Stortini's stands out as a pinnacle of American cuisine.

A photo of Marzano Italian Restaurant restaurant

3. Marzano Italian Restaurant

4.9

Exceptional(661)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Parkland

Booked 9 times today

Marzano Italian Restaurant is an exceptional eatery for Italian cuisine according to numerous positive reviews. Nestled near the PLU campus in Parkland, this restaurant is celebrated for its inventive appetizers, exceptional entrees, and delectable desserts. It offers superb Italian recipes that are simple yet of high quality, complimented by an extensive wine list featuring selections from all over the world including Italy and Columbia Valley. Patrons laud the outstanding food and service, remarking on the restaurant's homely ambiance, welcoming staff, and the exceptional experience it offers. From the best Caesar salads and Bruschetta to perfectly made pizza and pasta, the menu promises an unforgettable culinary journey. It's a gem that delivers intimate dining and is perfect for special occasions, date nights, or celebrations.

A photo of Over The Moon Cafe restaurant

4. Over The Moon Cafe

4.9

Exceptional(2527)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Tacoma

Booked 8 times today

"Over The Moon Cafe" is frequently lauded for its exceptional American cuisine, boasting a thoughtful menu filled with innovative meals that have been crafted with devotion and passion. With selections like Lobster Mac & Cheese, Duck Breast with Port Reduction Sauce, and House Made Bourbon Vanilla Ice Cream, the quality and flavor of the dishes speak for themselves. Reviews frequently commend the restaurant's excellent service, romantic ambiance, and dedication to using fresh, local ingredients. Additionally, the cafe has even been selected three times as one of the top one hundred most romantic restaurants in America, which clearly showcases its relevance to the American dining scene.

A photo of Italian Supper Club at Stadium Golf restaurant

5. Italian Supper Club at Stadium Golf

5.0

Exceptional(1)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Tacoma

Booked 2 times today

Gather ‘round with friends and family at Stadium Golf’s brand new dinner experience. Nestled in the heart of Stadium District, our Italian Supper Club is moving in for the summer featuring Chicago tavern-style pizza, lasagna, pasta, and meatballs so good you’ll forget your mama’s. But don’t take our word for it…come by and try our new menu for yourself before it’s gone! Available after 5:00pm Wednesday–Sunday. Serving cocktail classics like espresso martinis, spritz, and negronis alongside beer and wine. With our state-of-the-art Trackman golf simulator bays, two pool tables, and arcade games, we're all about having fun with friends! Bring the kids—all ages are welcome.

How is content generated

Discover best Italian restaurants in Puyallup

Discover the essence of Italian dining in the heart of Seattle's Eastern Washington regions, including Puyallup and Tacoma, where a variety of Italian restaurants offer a rich tapestry of culinary delights. These eateries blend traditional Italian flavors with local Northwest ingredients, creating a unique dining experience that caters to both classic and contemporary tastes. From cozy, family-style atmospheres to more sophisticated, gourmet settings, each restaurant serves up a menu filled with authentic Italian dishes like fresh seafood linguine, hearty pastas, and decadent desserts. The dining scene here is vibrant and diverse, reflecting the community's appreciation for genuine Italian cuisine alongside excellent service and inviting ambiances. Whether you're looking for a romantic dinner, a family gathering, or a special celebration, these Italian restaurants in Seattle's Eastern Washington area promise an unforgettable culinary journey.

Explore OpenTable

Puyallup

Italian