Best Seafood restaurants in Saint Simons

Price: Moderate (6)Price: Expensive (6)

8 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Ember - Saint Simons Island restaurant

1. Ember - Saint Simons Island

4.8

Exceptional(693)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Saint Simons

Booked 22 times today

Ember, located on Saint Simons Island, is highly lauded for its excellent farm-to-table cuisine. The restaurant consistently receives positive reviews, praising aspects from its charming setting and accommodating staff to its delectable menu. As one reviewer notes, Ember stands out due to its "farm-to-table with great veggies, and really delicious entrees." This focus on sourcing fresh, local ingredients enhances the overall dining experience and the quality of the dishes. The restaurant's commitment to the farm-to-table concept has even earned it the reputation of being "the best dining experience in St. Simon." Patrons highly recommend Ember for its delicious food and superb service.

A photo of Wolf Island Oyster Co. restaurant

2. Wolf Island Oyster Co.

new

4.3

Awesome(31)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Saint Simons

Booked 3 times today

Nestled in an undisclosed location, Wolf Island Oyster Co. is revered as a gem in Seafood cuisine. Their delicious dishes, accompanied by prompt and friendly service, have won the hearts of many. The slightly noisy ambiance is quickly forgotten given the quality of their offerings. The tastefully done interiors add to the overall dining experience. Meanwhile, their live music ensures a beautiful evening. As echoed in the reviews, the food and beverages are consistently wonderful, and the service, impeccable. Regardless of the mood or occasion, Wolf Island Oyster Co. never disappoints when it comes to a remarkable seafood extravaganza.

3. Georgia Sea Grill

4.8

Exceptional(3397)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Saint Simons

Booked 49 times today

Georgia Sea Grill is recognized for its award-winning seafood and exceptional service. This seafood hotspot, nestled on Saint Simons, has been praised for its consistent quality, with one patron stating, "In my opinion, it is the best Seafood Restaurant on Saint Simons." Its menu, boasting a variety of fresh fish preparations, has won both local and visiting diners. Highlights include the blackened special, crab chowder, calamari, and hush puppies. Along with its attention to flavor, the restaurant also excels in presentation, being tagged, "Food prepared with love, care. Food presentation excellent and tasted superb!" Its seafood specialities, impressive service, and inviting atmosphere contribute to Georgia Sea Grill's reputation as a must-visit dining destination.

A photo of Dorothy's Cocktail & Oyster Bar restaurant

4. Dorothy's Cocktail & Oyster Bar

new

4.7

Exceptional(278)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Saint Simons

Booked 8 times today

Dorothy's Cocktail & Oyster Bar on St. Simons Island is a haven for seafood lovers, with an emphasis on fresh oysters and an innovative selection of seafood dishes. The restaurant receives glowing reviews for its food, highlighting the diverse menu and the modern twist on classic seafood dishes. Customers applaud the seafood's freshness and variety, with one diner recalling their son's 30th birthday celebration at the restaurant, where everyone "thoroughly enjoyed all the selections." The ambiance is described as "lively, beautiful decor, fun bar scene," contributing to a memorable dining experience. The service is also highly recommended, noted as "spot on" and "excellent," making Dorothy's a standout choice for quality seafood.

A photo of ECHO St.Simons Island restaurant

5. ECHO St.Simons Island

4.2

Awesome(966)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Saint Simons

Booked 6 times today

Located on St. Simons Island, ECHO is celebrated for its exceptional Seafood cuisine. The menu is rich with delectable dishes that take full advantage of fresh seafood and local produce, cooked to perfection with a Southern "accent." Patrons praised its use of unique taste combinations that added depth to the meal. Standout dishes include tasty seafood staples like the *Tuna Poke Bowl, the Pan Seared Salmon, *Wild Georgia Shrimp Tacos, and *ECHO Shrimp & Grits. Reviewers also rave about the "best seafood omelet" and the "best flaky fish." ECHO is also known for its wonderful ambiance, offering breathtaking ocean views that complement the dining experience.

A photo of The Reserve Steak House restaurant

6. The Reserve Steak House

4.2

Awesome(408)

Price: Expensive

• Seafood • Jekyll Island

Booked 5 times today

The Reserve Steak House, located on the scenic Jekyll Island, is renowned for its exceptional American cuisine. With tantalizing reviews that commend the restaurant's ample use of fresh ingredients, expertly seasoned and cooked to perfection, it's no wonder it's considered a must-visit destination. Reviewers rave about the perfectly seasoned Ribeye, divine Angus filet, and delectable seafood platter. The immaculate service is also highly praised, with staff ensuring a memorable dining experience. Visitors have labelled it the best meal on the island, offering a quality dining experience coupled with a fantastic view of the dunes and the ocean. It's clear that The Reserve Steak House is the epitome of fine American dining.

A photo of Mr. Shucks Seafood restaurant

7. Mr. Shucks Seafood

4.7

Exceptional(165)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Brunswick

Booked 3 times today

Mr. Shucks Seafood is a standout for seafood cuisine by delivering a truly savory experience – a sentiment echoed frequently in customer reviews. Visitors have lauded the array of dishes, especially noting the blackened tilapia, garlic shrimp, and blue crabs for their exceptional taste. It's not just the seafood that gets all the credit though; side dishes like hush puppies, garlic potatoes, and coleslaw were also described as excellent. The restaurant boasts of a nice, quiet atmosphere with pleasant music, and the service is efficient and personable. Prices are said to be appropriate for the high-quality cuisine and generous servings. With plenty of satisfied customers promising to come back, despite being from out of town, it’s clear Mr. Shucks Seafood is the go-to for the best seafood experience.

A photo of Beach House Restaurant & Tap Room restaurant

8. Beach House Restaurant & Tap Room

3.1

Good(238)

Price: Moderate

• Seafood • Jekyll Island

Booked 2 times today

The Beach House Restaurant & Tap Room boasts of authentic American cuisine coupled with a stunning beachside location on Jekyll Island. The praise from visitors is consistent, highlighting particularly impressive dishes such as the Greens and Prime Rib, ribeye steak, and seafood specialties like shrimp and grits. Another standout item mentioned in reviews is the Oysters Rockefeller. Servers like Roddy and Brandon are commended for their exceptional service and helpful suggestions. Though some mention of slow service, the majority of reviews celebrate not only the excellent cuisine but also the comfortable, fun atmosphere and the welcoming staff. Whether it's for a casual meal or special events like Christmas dinner, the Beach House Restaurant & Tap Room appears to deliver a memorable dining experience with a lovely view of the ocean.

Explore OpenTable

Saint Simons

Seafood