Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. Caribbean

Diners' Choice: Best Overall restaurants in Caribbean

Red OpenTable logo
OpenTable
Updated November 05, 2024

Looking for the best overall restaurants in Caribbean? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favourite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!


A photo of Epicuro restaurant
5.0
5 (105)
$50 and over
Global, International
Condado
About the restaurant
True to its name, the Chef’s Table feels gloriously indulgent, inviting lucky diners on a hedonistic journey encapsulating Antonio Pérez’s life in Puerto Rico and his culinary career across South America, Europe, and Asia. The setting feels intimate and wildly special, with just 12 seats surrounding the open kitchen, complemented by a lounge area for a welcome cava before dinner or a post-tasting menu digestif. The themed-driven five-course menu changes monthly along with its wine pairing.
This is not merely another dining experience; it’s an intimate journey through the heart and soul of a Puerto Rican cook and his global culinary influences. Do not reserve a number of diners higher than desired, in our kitchen everything is prepared for all confirmed reservations, as such, we will regard it as a no show who has failed to comply with the reservation. If you wish to cancel your reservation, please give us at least three day’s notice. Thank you for your kindness and understanding.

Top review
Ricardo
Dined on Oct 24, 2024
Best Chef in PR hands down! Exquisite food paired with excellent selection of wines.
A photo of Terra-Mar Restaurant restaurant
5.0
5 (21)
$50 and over
International
Turks and Caicos
About the restaurant
The experience at Terra-Mar evolves around food and wine. We offer an unforgettable dining experience at our chef’s table, where an extensive 7 course Chef’s Impression will be prepared right before your eyes for $169 per person. To enhance your experience, we offer a carefully curated wine pairing for $99 per person. We welcome all our diners at 6:30PM with a glass of champagne to celebrate the night.

If you have any dietary restrictions or allergies inform us at reservations@terramartci.com so we can make your dinning experience exceptional.

Top review
Justaguyvip
Dined on Oct 31, 2024
Terra Mar is one of the great new, and yet undiscovered restaurants in T&C. An easy walk from Seven Stars/Ritz. Let me start by saying this is a Chef Table Experience - not an “order off the menu and choose what you like.” The Chef, Dennis has already created the menu which you can find online.” He can make minor variations for Gluten/Pork/sesame/nuts, etc; but not for dairy or seafood (come on - we’re on an island). The concept of a Chef’s Table is to “Leave it to the Chef to showcase his talents and present you with amazing dishes. At Terra Mar it’s a 7 course experience, paired with wine (if you choose). Yendy, the manager, has meticulously selected just the write wine for each dish. Our reservation was on Oct 31. There is one seating and it begins at 7. That evening there were only three reservations (3 couples). It was the last day of their summer menu, and they were excited to launch their new Fall menu the next day. The T&C high season begins in mid November. The “show” is graciously delivered by Dennis and Yendy. They do it all and it’s amazing to watch dishes prepared before your eyes. We had the benefit of being the only guests that evening as the first couple to arrive said they had a dairy allergy and since 7 out of 7 courses were made with butter and other dairy items, they couldn’t stay. The other couple was a no-show despite the reservation made by the hotel concierge. While I may have been disappointed as a restauranteur, they didn’t seemed phased. In fact,out experience was enhanced even further. This place is going to take off as soon as the area Concierges catch word. The pricing is fixed at $179/per person and $110/per person for the wine pairing. If you’re planning a trip to T&C make your reservations NOW! This place is sure to be a favorite tourist high-end dining experience for years to come . Tell them Laura and Marc from Boston sent you!!
A photo of Marmalade Restaurant & Wine Bar restaurant
5.0
5 (7437)
$50 and over
Fusion / Eclectic
San Juan
About the restaurant


Please note Marmalade only offers tasting menus, we do not offer children's menu or a la carte.

GROUPS OF 5 OR LESS ONLY, 5 course dinner @ $139.00. All guests pay full price including children, price is per seat.

GROUPS OF 6 OR MORE, Group tasting menu starting @$165.00. All guests pay full price including children, price is per seat.

Marmalade does not accept Discover credit cards

Top review
OpenTable Diner
Dined on Oct 28, 2024
Excellent food and service. Could not ask for anything more! Great place for a special occasion. Intimate, cozy seating arrangements and hardly any noise even when the place was almost full. Will definitely have to come back.
A photo of THE JOURNEY - To Culinary Excellence restaurant
5.0
5 (51)
$50 and over
International
Aruba
About the restaurant
Next to the 'Old Mill' in Aruba you'll find a unique new restaurant, 'The Journey'. Michelin star trained chef Patrick van der Donk (old Amuse Bistro) has made a very intimate chef's table concept.

Credit card information will be required in order to hold reservation as well confirmation by phone .

Not your usual bar seating set-up! Here you are able to dine at you own separate tables and still have a view of the chef creating your 5-course meal for a max of 20 guests per evening.
Price $130 per dinner and $80 for the optional wine paring, small bar available.
The evening starts on our cozy lounge with delicious hors d'oeuvres and bubbles, inside at a small and stylish set-up the chef will prepare every dish in front of his guests taking time to invite his guests over for a chat, he might even ask to help plating his dishes which gives a truly extraordinary dining experience. The menu changes frequently, classic dishes with a twist prepared with the best ingredients.

Top review
Jennavip
Dined on Oct 16, 2024
Best meal/experience in Aruba! The service was amazing and it was lovely getting to know the chef! Can’t wait to come back!
A photo of Bacaro restaurant
4.9
4.9 (55)
$31 to $50
Tapas / Small Plates
West Bay
About the restaurant
At Bàcaro, food and drink is our love language. Fresh, local ingredients, classic Venetian flavours and of course - a little modern innovation, ensure that everyone will find something they love.
Top review
Jeffvip
Dined 4 days ago
Excellent food and service and our waiter Simon was the absolute best! Highly highly recommend!
A photo of Aria restaurant
4.9
4.9 (110)
$31 to $50
Mediterranean
Grand Harbour
About the restaurant
At Aria, we pride ourselves on delivering superior quality throughout every aspect of the dining experience, every time. Expect the freshest, highest quality ingredients, knowledgeable staff, exceptional service, and a beautifully designed, modern space.

We’re the leading innovator in Mediterranean cuisine on the island, with chefs hand-picked from across the Mediterranean. Our menu honors the history and heritage of the food, while still managing to be fresh and modern.

And as part of the Agua Hospitality Group our guests can expect the same superior quality and experience they have come to enjoy at our other establishments.

For event inquiries, please visit: https://www.ariacayman.ky/events

Top review
LAURA
Dined on Nov 1, 2024
An amazing experience, could not fault it! The date night deal is such good value, the food was the best we’ve had on island, the service was fantastic, so attentive to all our needs. We’ll be back tomorrow with a big group, we can not wait to see what they have in store for us. Thanks so much Aria!
A photo of L'Olivo restaurant
4.9
4.9 (204)
$31 to $50
Mediterranean
Hato Rey Norte
About the restaurant
RESTAURANTE MEDITERRÁNEO Cocina inspirada por los ingredientes frescos, colores y sabores del mar en medio de tierras. Una fusión provocadora del gusto clásico del viejo mundo con las tendencias gastronómicas del presente.
Top review
WandaG
Dined 4 days ago
Very nice service, and the food outstanding. Very nice ambiance
A photo of Wilo Eatery & Bar restaurant
4.9
4.9 (569)
$31 to $50
International
Guaynabo
About the restaurant
The new Wilo Benet culinary experience is here and it's cooking! After 28 years of running Pikayo, get ready for the evolution of our great flavors and services at our new location, Wilo Eatery & Bar!
Top review
Rafaelvip
Dined 4 days ago
As always Wilo delivers the highest quality food and stellar service.
A photo of Oceana Restaurant and Bistro restaurant
4.9
4.9 (379)
$31 to $50
Global, International
St Thomas
About the restaurant

Overlooking the aqua colors of the Caribbean Sea, our restaurant is regarded as the island’s most iconic location for dining. We feature a fully open-air dining room. Most tables offer unobstructed views of the Baye de GriGri, spectacular breathtaking sunsets, dramatic full moons rising, passing sailboats and landing seaplanes.

Unsurprisingly, seafood dominates our menu. Whenever possible we source fresh, local seafood caught off the shores of the Virgin Islands.

We hope our passion for sustainability is evident in the highest quality and freshest ingredients we use, including seasonal produce from local farmers.

Our extensive wine list was chosen to balance refinement with versatility and intended to pair well with every item on our menu.

Our Bistro offers a fun, lively atmosphere designed with a come-as-you-are feeling.

We combine culinary excellence with superb service and an exquisite setting, creating experiences and

Top review
Donna
Dined 2 days ago
It was a special dining experience besides the delicious food the sound of the ocean waves was amazing
A photo of Ever Restaurant restaurant
4.9
4.9 (186)
$50 and over
International
Aruba
About the restaurant
Ever Restaurant Aruba is a freestyle fine dining experience on the Oranjestad marina at the Harbour House Condos. Chef Ever de Peña takes center stage in the open kitchen to showcase his love for culinary arts.

Settle into our dining room with seating for up to 14 guests, and let your appetite take the lead to an 7-course dinner menu. Our set menu focuses on fish, selfish, meat courses, and dessert.

Seating
We are open Monday – Saturday for one seating:
7.00pm - 11.00 pm / 7-Course Menu

Top review
yvette
Dined 6 days ago
Staff was amazing, food was really good wish there was more of it!
Explore Diners' Choice best of Caribbean
Explore more Diners' Choice lists
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo