Hy's Steakhouse - Winnipeg
Famously irresistible since 1955
Went to Hy’s to celebrate our 30th wedding anniversary. Food and service was top notch. One of the finest French onion soup to start. Followed up with a spectacularly prepared and tasting filet steak complimented by baked potato, cream corn and glazed carrots.
Evening was finished with a Belgian chocolate bourbon cake with ice cream.
When you share this with the most beautiful and intelligent woman ever it does not get any better !!!
The food and service are outstanding.
Consistent. Very pricey. Food is good but not outstanding. Service was good. Nice evening overall.
The environment and service is nice but the food was bland and very average tasting. For the price I would have expected an outstanding meal and it was just kind “meh”.
Amazing service and awesome food. My wife and I had a wonderful dinner. We will definitely be going again.
It was a lovely evening. Service was excellent! And too was quite good!
Overall it was a nice evening. Staff were great looking to please at all times.
As for the food, many components were very good however I could not rate the steak as much more than average. It was probably the cut, but I had grizzle/tendon whatever they call it with each bite. For the price, that cut should’ve of been on my plate. Meat was delicious but had to work my way at it with each bite.
As for the rest, appetizers, sides and desert, delicious.
However it’s Hy’s Steakhouse and the steak was not the best.
Food was very disappointing. Service and ambiance were great.
Great escargot! Steak war great, waiter talked over us at times
Everything was wonderful, from the very nice waiting staff to the dishes we received. However, I paid part of my bill in cash and when the waiter went to put the remaining balance into the machine, he choose tip amount for me. I serve in a lounge nearby and found this extremely disrespectful. I would have tipped him a proper amount but I guess he judged myself and my partner off our *assumed* age and made a selfish decision. (I still left a good tip for him because I understand how he felt but I personally would never do that to guest).
We ordered filet mingon, beef Wellington and filet a la hys and every single dish was outstanding. The experience was nothing but first class from beginning to end. Can’t recommend enough.
This is our go to restaurant for special occasions. But after being in our home for such a long time, we decided to have a night out with some friends ( social distancing). As always the food and service was top notch. Just what we needed to feel somewhat normal again.
Great service, great food. Andrew was very knowledgeable and helpful.
The service was excellent and we felt comfortable with precautions put in place for COVID-19. The food was excellent l. The server has been with Hy's for about 10 years and always provide excellent service.
Cameron was top notch and the food was perrrrrfect!
Hello Alexander, Thank-you for the 5 star review we will be sure to point out Cameron's efforts in our next pre-service meeting. Warm Regards, Jason Sohor General Manager
Food was amazing as was our waiter Andrew.
We were a party of 4 and everyone’s meals were perfect.
Our waiter was attentive and funny making for a very enjoyable evening.
Hello Sue, Thank-you for the kind review, I will be sure to pass along your compliments to Andrew and our team. Warm Regards, Jason Sohor General Manager
the chairs and settees are due for a good cleaning - i usually do nt frequent this kind of establishment, but i found what we rec'd for the price was a little on the skimpy side. My partner had the filet with fries and the fries were of the frozen variety, for the price i expected real fries.
Hello Gerald, Thank-you for taking the time to give us your feedback, we will be sure to use this review to better our efforts. Regards, Jason Sohor General Manager
Birthday and anniversary
Hadn’t been in 2 years, and will likely wait another 2 years to return! Overall it was good, but not as good as it use to be. Back in the day at the old location, it was outstanding! It was more than a meal, it was an experience! It’s lost some of that for me. Music was too loud and ruined the ambiance, sounded like a radio station; Caesar salad was not freshly made at the table. The food was delicious but for the money and lack of ambiance, you could have gone to The Keg. Having said all that, their cheese toast is still the BEST!
Hello, I am sorry to hear that your dining experience did not hold up to our high standards. I thank-you for taking the time to give us your feed back, and we will most certainly learn from this. Tableside has been suspended due to Covid-19, but we are optimistic that we can get back to preforming all our guests favorites beside their table again. Again I thank-you for your time, this is the best way for us to improve. Warm Regards, Jason Sohor General Manager 204-942-1000
Great lunch with friends. Attentive service from Cameron, all food prepared very well and enjoyed the meal. Caesar salad with steak, caesar salad with grilled prawn, and a broiled pickeral fillet. Dessert was perfect as well. Drinks were red wine sangrias and house pinot. All very good.
Construction on the plaza outside stopped during lunch and was not a concern. Will definitely return.
Hello Robert, Thank-you so much for the review, we will be sure to pass on the compliments to Cameron and our team. I am also glad the construction wasn't a issue outside. Have a great week-end. Regards, Jason Sohor General Manager
Gorgeous place and amazing service, but overpriced for the food that it is. Food isn’t anything too special and no different than other restaurants, but much more expensive.
Celebrated our 30th wedding anniversary in style. Food was absolutely fantastic, service impeccable, and the atmosphere exactly what we wanted. Would highly recommend for any special occasion.
Hello Kim, I am so happy to hear that your anniversary was perfect. We do take special occasions very seriously and we look forward to seeing you again soon. Happy Anniversary again! Jason Sohor General Manager
As always Hy’s is a fantastic place for any celebration Staff is fabulous food is scrumptious
Hello Diana, I will be sure to pass on your kind words at today's staff meeting. Thank-you again, Jason Sohor General Manager
Service was fantastic; food was outstanding and with social distancing it was quiet. Hopefully, this will be the new norm - quiet that is. Koodos to all the staff.
The service and food was very good as always. The special was delicious.
I love Hy’s. It’s a classic, classy steak house in a great atmosphere. They don’t do lot, but they do what they do, really well.
Ooh, that filet!
High School grad family dinner
My Husband, myself, and our best friends visited Hy's to celebrate mine & my Husband's 19th wedding Anniversary. 6/23/2020
The service was terrific, the staff was friendly and kind, as they always are!
The appetizers were great, salad was great. But when our steak dinners were served, we were quite disappointed. Our steaks were not the usual Hy's quality! The crab meat on the Neptune steak was terrible, and didn't get as much as I usually do. The asparagus was overcooked ( mush) mashed potatoes were cold, and the bernaise looked, and tasted like it sat out overnight, it was coagulated..EWW! The meal was not the typical Hy's caliber, we barely ate it. Could have had that quality at Earls for way less money. We visit HY's as much as we can, and only a few times I've been served a bad steak. But this was by far the worst meal I've had at Hy's, and it's not cheap to dine there. So that being said, I'm quite disappointed, especially on our special day. We visit Hy's for the high scale quality, and it was upsetting that we didn't receive it. So going forward, will I recommend Hy's? I always have, but I do think it's quite important to give my review.
Overall great experience, service was superb...thanks Kelly....even with the mask we could tell you were smiling under it! I had the Steak Neptune and sadly would not order it again...the steak was quite bland. Two of our party had Peppercorn filet and enjoyed it, your other guest had salmon and enjoyed it. So one out of four is pretty good. Celebrating anniversary and birthday so were treated to bourbon chocolate cake and salt caramel creme brûlée...excellent....was expensive but enjoyable.
service was amazing, waiter always made sure we had water and that everything was perfect
Yummy & beautiful atmosphere.
Service was impeccable
Way too expensive for you what you. The steak and lobster is $76 and you get the tiniest steak ever. Major rip off. Service was amazing and beef Wellington was incredible.