Best Mexican restaurants in New York / Tri-State Area

$$$$ (424)$$$$ (411)$$$$ (165)

45 restaurants available nearby

1. Tito Murphy's

4.1

Excellent(796)

$$$$

• Mexican • Theater District / Times Square

Booked 50 times today

Great spot for a pre-theater dinner. Very reasonably priced for dinner in Manhattan. Tacos al pastor were packed with meat and amazingly delicious. Also highly recommend some elote to start.

A photo of Agave - Columbus Ave restaurant

2. Agave - Columbus Ave

4.1

Excellent(30)

$$$$

• Mexican • Upper West Side

Booked 9 times today

The food and service were great. We went on a Friday night at 7:00 and were very surprised that the place was only half-full, as we usually see a nice crowd there (the porch was closed due to cool weather). The live music wasn’t great, though.

3. Playa Betty's

4.4

Awesome(913)

$$$$

• Mexican • Upper West Side

Booked 57 times today

Overall ok for a casual dinner. Drinks were not great

A photo of Dos Caminos - Times Square restaurant

4. Dos Caminos - Times Square

4.1

Excellent(2053)

$$$$

• Mexican • Theater District / Times Square

Booked 87 times today

Visiting New York, best Mexican food hands down… Will eat here again on our next visit.

A photo of Rosa Mexicano - Union Square restaurant

5. Rosa Mexicano - Union Square

4.3

Awesome(4864)

$$$$

• Mexican • Union Square

Booked 118 times today

Good good, spacious restaurant. However, The two ladies who were the hosts and seating arriving clients could not be more cold and rude to us when we arrived, and we had a reservation. Someone needs to talk to them. They barely acknowledged us when we arrived.

A photo of Rosa Mexicano by Lincoln Center restaurant

6. Rosa Mexicano by Lincoln Center

4.2

Awesome(8523)

$$$$

• Mexican • Lincoln Square

Booked 156 times today

My 4 friends who has never been here before were very appreciative to be introduced to Rosa Mexicano. Good food, excellent service.

7. The Black Ant

4.5

Awesome(539)

$$$$

• Mexican • East Village

Booked 16 times today

Great restaurant with great service. Sit in the patio it’s gorgeous

8. Toloache-Midtown

4.6

Exceptional(7090)

$$$$

• Mexican • Theater District / Times Square

Booked 64 times today

We went to Toloache after seeing Hamilton and it was a great experience! We were seated 5 minutes before our reservation time and our server came over quickly to get our drink orders. The passion fruit margarita was so good! The food was out of this world. We ordered the Queso Fundido and my husband commented that it was the best bite of food he’d ever had. Not too salty-perfectly balanced. Our only critique was the rojo spicy guacamole was not hot at all. It was still delicious but we wanted a real kick. The Birria taco was the best I’ve ever had and honestly is a must try if you visit. Everyone that worked there was pleasant and made us feel so welcomed. Also the playlist was great

A photo of Toloache - Upper East Side restaurant

9. Toloache - Upper East Side

4.7

Exceptional(1413)

$$$$

• Mexican • Upper East Side

Booked 62 times today

Great food, warm staff and an upbeat atmosphere. Perfect for a fun casual night out. Be sure to make a reservation in advance, Toloache is popular.

A photo of Tacuba Hell's Kitchen restaurant

10. Tacuba Hell's Kitchen

4.7

Exceptional(1274)

$$$$

• Mexican • Hell's Kitchen

Booked 41 times today

We had a wonderful experience and tasty meal. Got there in time to enjoy happy hour and the margaritas were spot on. Thank you to everyone who waited on us!

Best Mexican restaurants in New York / Tri-State Area

Price

45 restaurants available nearby

1. Tito Murphy's

2. Agave - Columbus Ave

3. Playa Betty's

4. Dos Caminos - Times Square

5. Rosa Mexicano - Union Square

6. Rosa Mexicano by Lincoln Center

7. The Black Ant

8. Toloache-Midtown

9. Toloache - Upper East Side

10. Tacuba Hell's Kitchen

Explore OpenTable