Wading River Restaurants

We loved our first experience with Pulcinella so much Saturday night that we came back Sunday for an early dinner. We ordered a variety of selections off the menu. Each and every choice was delicious! Our waitress this evening, MariaRosa, shocked us with her memory of their very long specials menu. She was pleasant and always had the drinks coming to the table. Our waitress, Dylan, Saturday evening was just as in point. Order the pasta tossed in the cheese wheel table side. You won’t be disappointed! Excellent experience both nights! We will be back!

It was great! Only thing it wasn't dinner music very loud! Also was very cold in there! People were saying felt like winter lol air was pumping!

Excellent restaurant for family or individuals food is great and portions are plentiful

Generally, the food is always excellent. However, with this visit, the only thing that was not up to par with dessert. We ordered the lava cakes which were over cooked and we also ordered cappuccinos, which were very bitter. Other than that the drinks. Entrées service was excellent everyone’s entitled to have a missed opportunity.

Our time here at Cooperage Inn was excellent. We went on New Years Day with reservations as we were not sure how busy it would be. We recommend making reservations as they became busy as time went on. Our server was JoAnne and she was awesome. Very friendly and professional. She was a delight. We ordered the garden salad and French onion soup to start and both were fresh and delicious. It was a no brainer for us both to order the classic chicken pot pie as this is a staple here. The best restaurant pot pie by far. Unbelievably good !! A real nice wine list and craft beer selection. They also offer a 10% discount for any pot pie take away with your table receipt. We will be back !!!