Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.
Benjamin Steakhouse Prime
- Surfaces sanitised between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitised menu provided
- Sanitiser or wipes provided for customers
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Proof of vaccination required to dine indoors
Porterhouse for Four
USDA Prime, dry aged
I went to this restaurant after reading all the good reviews here, and unfortunately it was very underwhelming. The food was decent, the service was crude, the tasteless 90’s music definitely wasn’t cut out for the venue. Very disappointing and I won’t come back here. I see why there are always the reservation availabilities.
It was a slow sunday night, and we were seated at a small table despite several larger tables available. We didnt mention it assuming the larger tables were reserved for larger parties, just to later see other groups of two being seated at the larger tables. My husbnd was wearing an arm sling which more space would have helped for sure and we did in fact make prior reservations. I spite of this, we were treated as less important.
I hope this has nothing to do with us being Asian because it’s common for restaurants to seat Asian people in the corner where they can’t be seen to the crowd.
Service was rushed. Check was brought to us before we even had a chance to make last calls.
Food was excellent. Waiters were friendly, personable and excellent at their job. Really loved the relaxed vibe inside the restaurant
Great experience I come here all the time for lunch so I brought my father it was a great surprise he loved it
Service, Food and overall experience was very enjoyable.
Excellent food and service.
Benjamin Prime is always simply great! My wife and i have been enjoying wonderful meals and relationship for nearly 5 years at Benjamin Prime and will continue to do so!
Sat at the bar, service by Adrian was superb. Food was fantastic. We had a great evening!
Service and food were both phenomenal. Would dine here again in a heartbeat.
We love to spend the New Year’s Eve in this high end quality remarkable restaurant. The environment was very positive and we flew from San Francisco California to spend the New Year Eve in the great city ever as New York. We really appreciate the quality and outstanding service the waiter Cris ( Ecuadorian) have to us. He was so polite, charismatic with very well knowledge about the food. His service was remarkable. The porterhouse steak was delicious and the seafood platter very tasty.
Great food and steak was cooked perfectly. We’ll definitely come back and recommend this place to a friend
Only a few bottles of wine under $100. I don't mind spending on the food but when you ask the sommelier to recommend a bottle under $100 and they give you 2 options: $125 and $135 it's a problem. Obviously the customer is not always right here.
Always awesome! Sean and team are the best!!
The waiters were so lovely - very attentive. Food was delicious!
We enjoyed the raw bar and our entrees very much! Steaks were great, seafood was delicious; a bit stingy on the portions of seafood. Steak portions were generous.
Amazing steak , best in the city and service top notch
Food is great. But the staff was unfriendly. Need to improve the services.
We thoroughly enjoyed our dinner at Benjamin Steakhouse Prime. The service by our waiter, Tony, was excellent and we will return the next time we're in NYC!
Loved Benjamin's...the steak was delish and the service was top notch!
Rush our Service. Sorry geht gar nicht.
We enjoyed a memorable evening. First of all our
Server Donni was fantastic. Very knowledgeable of
The menu and professional.
We wanted a special meal for Christmas week-end and we really accomplished this. We started with Caviar and prosecco.It was delicious. The presentation was world class. Our
Entrees were also delicious. My rack of lamb was
Cooked to perfection. My wife ordered scallops and they were exactly as ordered. She wanted them
Browned but not well done. They were sweet and crispy.
Donni always kept an eye on the table without being
Intrusive. Dessert was warm bourbon pecan pie and
TRULY A MEMORABLE EXPERIENCE
The waiter was awful. He messed up every part of our order and our check. He seemed sarcastic but in a bad way
An amazing Christmas Day dinner! We had the set menu which included a glass of holiday eggnog and everything was delicious. The bone in rib-eyes were HUGE and cooked perfectly! Service was great but we had a 30 min wait for our table and it was a little while before our order was taken but it was very busy so that was understandable. Such great value for money and a really gorgeous place to spend Christmas evening - definitely recommend!
Christmas dinner was fantastic. Great service, excelled pre fixed menu. The filet mignon melted in my mouth; highly recommend.
Très mauvais service.
On nous a jamais apporté le pain, j ai du demande 3 fois du vin et les autres tables avaient un apéritif de bienvenue,
En revanche bonne viande
We had such an amazing Christmas dinner here, the staff was amazing along with incredible food and ambiance. I would highly recommend Benjamin Steakhouse Prime.
Absolutely incredible. The meal was fantastic and the value for money was out of this world. We had the $89 Christmas menu and the steaks were worth that price alone. Couldn’t fault anything. Perfect meal.
Everyone pleasant from start to finish! Drinks and food very good! Would highly recommend!! Pricey as most Manhattan restaurants are!!
Amazing staff Is incredible and food outstanding!
Outstanding way to celebrate Christmas with my family! Delicious, festive and fun!
Delicious filet mignon, beautiful locale. Served with a smile.
My husband and I wanted to visit NYC for Christmas. We came from Orange County, CA. We loved our experience here. Steaks were cooked perfectly, sides were delicious, and so were the desserts. Friendly staff. Lovely holiday decorations. Would definitely recommend.
Wonderful dining experience. Perfect ambiance, impeccable service and great food. Will definitely return.
$90.00 3course meal which was a simple and tasty selection. Choose 1 appetizer, 1 entree, 1 side, and 1 dessert per person.
Thank you! It was a pleasant dining experience.
Steaks were outstanding as were the sides. They also made great Old Fashioneds.
Staff was very nice and we enjoyed our date a lot!
Food was great server was poornever introduced himself never discussed chef specials had to wait to see him everytime we needed a glass of wine water glasses were always empty
Lobster and ribe eye are great same as onion soup!
Steaks were ok, but service not that attentive. The restaurant came highly recommended and maybe just an off day. Expected more for $600 dinner.
We had a wonderful experience. The food was delicious, the service was great and the ambience was amazing. Nice music streaming.
You can order delivery directly from Benjamin Steakhouse Prime using the Order Online button. Benjamin Steakhouse Prime also offers takeaway which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 338-0818.
Benjamin Steakhouse Prime is rated 4.7 stars by 1345 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.