Gargiulos Tinton Falls
4-Course Fall Wine Pairing Dinner$126.62 per personPrepaid
Nov 11, 2021 only**We will only be offering the Wine Pairing Menu - Regular dinner service will not be available** Come and enjoy our 4-course fall harvest menu with a curated selection of Italian wines paired for each dish. Visit our website to view the full menu! www.gargiulostf.com
- Surfaces sanitised between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitised menu provided
- Sanitiser or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
fried OR racanati
cannellini beans, tomato broth, onions, & pasta
w. fried polenta & roasted carrots in a red wine sauce
Food is ALWAYS good. Chef Daryl and his team do an amazing job. Family owned and they pour themselves into every corner of this place. Go. Eat. Enjoy..
Great Drinks awesome Stuffed Artichoke. Superb and perfectly cooked Halibut, excellent Chicken Scarparellio dish. Tartuffo to die for. Friendly staff, spacious seating. Can be loud as everyone is having a great time. Our go to in Tinton Falls. Bread n butter could use an upgrade.
All good 👍
We love coming here. The staff takes time to talk to guests and make you feel like family. Food is amazing and atmosphere is as well. We love finishing the night off at the outdoor fire pit.
The food was tasteless. This my first time going and I brought my fiancé to celebrate a work event. I spent a lot of money on a meal I didn’t enjoy.
Ate here in the past when it was Portofino's and remember it being really good. New ownership, food was OK my Chicken Parm wa a bit on the tough side, same with the Calamari. Would probably not go back as it was not what I expected and their are other Italian restaurants that are honestly better and lower cost.
First time here. , from valet to bartender/ server. Cant say enough 5 star experience, meals were incredible , cant wait to go back , this will become one of my regular dining spots
Always a great meal with wonderful people. Go and try it... you won't be disappointed.
We’ve been to Gargiulo’s a few times and have always enjoyed our meals. Definitely would recommend dining here.
Excellent food, even better cocktails. An overall great experience.
Perfect dinner! Out with friends :)
I'm so happy Coney Island came to Jersey! My family (the Ruggiero's of West 16th street) booked Gargiulos for all occasions. It was great to visit the Tinton falls location. The ambience was stunning, Faith (our waitress) and Gianna were absolutely wonderful and the the food, just as I expected...delicious! Can't wait to come back!
Food had no flavor at all. We went for a birthday dinner. Oh well....
Such a cute place I didn’t even know about. The food was great as well as the service. Now that we know it’s there we will definitely be coming back.
Went for the first time for a small birthday dinner. Can’t say enough great things. Waiting staff was amazing and informative. Love how dinner was not rushed. All of the food was phenomenal and such a welcoming place. Will definitely be back
Our new favorite place! Gorgeous indoor or outdoor seating, amazing wine list, and incredible Italian cuisine, and the service is friendly and prompt. Check out this place if you haven’t tried it yet!
Food and service were excellent.
Meet some friends we ordered a Johnny black each we received the smallest scotch I have ever gotten in a restaurant definitely not the colts neck inn next time we’ll skip the drinks
Loved everything about our evening out! From the warm greeting to the goodbye was excellent. Our server was great and the food was delicious.
We will definitely return.
Good Italian food. Nothing fancy, But good food and service
Very nice with solid cuisine. Wine list is pricey
I thoroughly enjoyed the food and our server Scott was friendly and knowledgeable. I highly recommend the cheese board and red wine.
The food was excellent. The server was outstanding. Funny, friendly and attentive without being overly so.
We enjoyed ourselves very much. Our friend, who is from Italy, said the rice balls were incredible! Better than the ones his mother used to make.
Overall a wonderful evening.
Lovely cocktails, satisfying entrees, bad dessert. Service was outstanding.
Always a good meal and great service. Love this small town hidden gem!
Gargiulo’s has a pleasant atmosphere and the staff is courteous. There isn’t much parking so you must valet. The baked clams were very good. We didn’t order the calamari, which I think turned out to be a good thing. We saw someone else’s order and it was huge (much more than the two of us needed). The cocktails are unfortunately overpriced. The cioppino was not cioppino. It was more a frutta de mar (?sp). Although it tasted good for whatnot was. The fettuccine Gargiulo’s had a great sauce and what I believe is homemade pasta but the chicken was dry. Overall, a decent meal and perhaps of reasonable price if you don’t get $15 drinks.
Quaint setting..Tuscan atmosphere..a little bit of Italy!..Service was friendly and the food… delicious!! …..Bellissimo!!
Drinks and pear salad where very good. The main courses where lacking flavor and quality especially for the price.
Dinner as always was delicious and the service was excellent, also.
Nice atmosphere and great food. Nice little bar area and a simple but fun cocktail menu.
Its been a tough time for restaurants, short staffs and trying to find capable help must be a real challenge. To give a review now would be wrong. This is a nice restaurant , Nice people, great staff, energy in the place is high. We will try it again after this mess is over
Our waitress was friendly and attentive. Food was excellent. We’ll definitely return.
Everything was wonderful from start to finish including the wine with dinner and whiskey that our husbands enjoyed. Will definitely be back!
Victor and his staff are outstanding!
Excellent food and very good service We ate early so not crowded. This was our second time there and we will definitely go back. Would definitely recommend this restaurant.
Friendly and very accommodating! Food was delicious. We were not rushed. A very pleasant experience!
Always a good time here. Pleasant staff and excellent food at a great price. The filet of sole racanati was outstanding! Awesome drinks too.
Very disappointed last night.
We had dinner reservations for 7pm.
Against our better judgement, server suggested to put in our entire order all at once and ASSURED us we wouldn’t be rushed…..
By 7:30pm, we received our drinks, appetizers, and entrees—all within five minutes of each other. The appetizer came before the drinks. The dinner came after two bites of appetizer. Even the server was surprised. Funny not funny. My eggplant parmigiana was flavorless and luke warm at best. I made no complaint (I never send back food but I should’ve) but the server KNEW I was unhappy. We had to flag down a busgirl for a proper steak knife for the rack of lamb since we weren’t given one.
As much as we liked our server (we had him before and won’t mention his name), he did NOTHING to rectify the situation. It was apparent we weren’t very important to him last night. Gargiulios, please take a lesson from your Coney Island location. Too many better restaurants around here for anyone to be subjected to this sub par rush job. We won’t be back. Sorry.
Our server, Scott, was fantastic!! The food and drink were exceptional. Outside ambiance is as peaceful. Highly recommend dinner at Gargiulos.
Gargiulos Tinton Falls offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (732) 389-9100.
Gargiulos Tinton Falls is rated 4.5 stars by 407 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.