Macelleria Italian Steakhouse
Macelleria Italian Steakhouse offers a gourmet assortment of Italian cuisine, Steak, Chops and seafood, alongside an expertly curated wine list. Everything made by hand from the freshest ingredients. Whether you are gathering for a private dining, a special occasion, a business lunch, or an dinner party, Macelleria Italian Steakhouse is the perfect restaurant and event venue.
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Sanitiser or wipes provided for customers
- Extra space between tables
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
hand cut filet mignon, capers, tabasco, aioli, egg yolk
shrimp, scallops, crab meat, octopus, calamari, arugula, lemon vinaigrette
Zuppa di Pesce
mixed seafood, garlic, lemon, white wine, fresh basil
What used to set Macelleria apart from the typical New York or Westchester steak house was its prices; it cost significantly lees than its brethren. No more. Sometime between the summer and now Macellaria raised its prices, in some cases by as much as 50%, so that now it is no longer a bargain. Steaks that were $39 dollars are now $58-60. Sides have gone from $5-6 to $10-12. Starters that were all less than $20 previously now are in the $24-26 range. The food is the same - excellent quality meat and seafood very well prepared and presented. But, where before, if it was a choice between Benjamin Steak House in Hartsdale or STK in White Plains or Macellaria in Pelham, Pelham would win based on equal quality but much better pricing, that difference has now evaporated.
Food and service very good. Great ambiance. Will go back. Branzino was excellent.
This is what happens when Albanians try to cook Italian. Skip it!
Excellent service, excellent food , great experience
It was a nice place. I was disappointed that they don't have a bar and they didn't have sweet vermouth for a cocktail. I was very disappointed that the dry aged steak had zero dry age flavor. Taking a choice steak and soaking it in butter does not turn it into a prime dry aged steak. But it was prepared nicely and the side were good.
Our experience was excellent!
The food & service was great.
We will back soon !
New York City fine dining comes to Pelham. A wonderful experience.
Great service as always
My friend and I came here to celebrate his birthday. The overall experience was excellent. The ambiance was very comfortable and relaxed. The service was impeccable. Everyone was very attentive, knowledgeable about the menu, and patient with all of our questions. The food was excellently cooked to our requests and we did not have any complaints. They surprised my friend with a complimentary dessert to celebrate his birthday. It was a wonderful experience and can’t wait to return.
Prices on meats and some other items have gone up significantly (20-40%) in 24 hrs.. aside from that all in all solid experience
Excellent food and ambiance. Service also excellent
The place was slammed so of course it was so noisy! Most of the things we are had were pretty good, not everything. Strange minestrone, and I asked if the fries were fresh cut and they said yes. NO!
We will go again and see what happens!
Absolutely delicious cooked lamb medium and very tender.
Excellent best porterhouse steak ever ! We will be back
The food was trash I order spaghetti for my child with white Alfredo sauce and they bring her a dry pasta no sauce it taste like garlic only the sprite taste nasty they didn’t even had a drink menu I order a apple martini and it was only vodka my gravy for my mash potatoes 👎👎👎👎
Good was excellent and reasonably priced. Steaks were grilled to perfection
Food was cold and staff not very good.
My veal chop was melt-in-your-mouth delicious. Will visit again
Very reasonably priced and attentive service. Great wine list. The octopus was perfectly prepared and very tender. The sole is 2 thumbs up. The Cornish hen was a little dry, but all in all a great value.
The place was pretty chill. The service was phenomenal all of the waiters have amazing accents which is pretty funny. Overall great vibe!
Great food and friendly staff!
Pricey but food was delicious. Service was excellent
I had Chicken Scarpiello and my fellow diner had Short Ribs. The complementary Grappa was delicious. The steak looked phenomenal. I asked the people who ordered it how it was and they said "great". This would be a complete 5 Star experience except for the brown whisky selection which has a few recognizable names but could use some new blood.
Food was great. Service was spot on.
Awesome restaurant !
The food and service was outstanding!! My husband and I enjoyed the evening very much! There prices are very reasonable , portions are very nice ! Can’t wait to have dinner there again ❤️
Have eaten here many times; our go-to neighborhood steak place. Now with greatly-expanded total seating capacity (expanded outdoors), courtesy of COVID. On this particular visit, the food seemed to be over-salted. Also, an unacceptable length of time between completion and clearance of appetizers and delivery of main courses to table. This was a weeknight and the place just was not that busy to justify the delay.
But - still like the p,ace and will look forward to a better experience next time.
Great local Pelham establishment
Perfect outdoor patio on sidewalk perfectly covered plants white table clothes
Food…Italian and perfectly presented great attentive waiters good wine choices.
Pasta very nice and good seafood and steaks
Try the burrata, the mini meatballs are nice.
Could use heated bread to be perfect!
If you live near Pelham,try it!
Date night with husband. We sat outside and it was beautiful. Food was tasty and plentiful. I had the sea bass and husband had the rib eye. All staff was attentive and definitely would go back.
Meats are top quality and a great value! Good service and I highly recommend!
Love Macelleria! Great food and service and the outdoor terrace makes me feel like I’m somewhere far more exotic than Pelham ;)
Food was excellent-service was great and attentive-ambience delightful-and great prices. No wonder Michelin highly recommends it. Wonderful dining experience.
Excellent Italian Seafood and Meats with a very good wine list. Service was good and outside seating was nice. Steaks were excellent and reasonably priced
We had an excellent meal from start to finish. Standouts were the octopus and the bacon!. The main courses were wonderful - highly recommend the short ribs! Service was attentive and wonderful. All of this in a beautiful outdoor setting on a quiet street. A wonderful experience well worth returning to again.
Everything was excellent. We had a party of seven and everyone's food was perfect. My daughter asked for her steak well done and it was charred - it was pretty bad, but she didn't complain. Everyone was so happy w their meal, no one thought to ask her. Everything else was great.
Birthday dinner was delicious. One of us ordered rib eye cooked to perfection & the other ordered Zuppa de peche which was also delicious. Looking forward to returning soon!
Everything was excellent.
Food and service are excellent but menu prices have become unaffordable.
Wonderful service and menu knowledge, good recommendations and daily specials.
The ambiance was lovely. The staff was very attentive and provided excellent customer care. They went above and beyond. The owner came out and wished us a happy anniversary, he was very friendly and we will definitely be back! Oh and our apple martinis were delicious !
Macelleria Italian Steakhouse is rated 4.6 stars by 339 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.