Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York / Tri-State Area
  4. Long Island / Hamptons
  5. Bayville
Mill Creek Tavern, Bayville, NY
This restaurant now offers Takeout

This restaurant now offers Takeout

Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.

Mill Creek Tavern

4.7
4.7
773 Reviews
$30 and under
American
Mill Creek Tavern is a cozy and warm neighborhood restaurant with big city cuisine, served in an intimate dining room and outdoor tent with exquisite menu selections. Start with the Tuscan Calamari, French Onion soup, or one of our delicious Mussel pots. Enjoy entrees like Sauerbraten Short Ribs, Pan Seared Sea Scallops, or USDA Prime NY Sirloin. Be sure to save room for Campfire S'mores, Homemade Key Lime Pie, Oreo Moose Cake or try them all with our Dessert Sampler.

Make a reservation

2 people

7:00 p.m.


Booked 4 times today

Additional information

  • Dining style

    Casual Elegant

  • Cuisines

    American, Californian, Contemporary American

  • Hours of Operation

    Dinner Tue–Sun 4:30 pm–9:00 pm

  • Phone number

    (516) 628-2000

  • Payment Options

    AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa

  • Dress Code

    Casual Dress

  • Executive Chef

    Julio Cruz

  • Catering

    Speak to our catering manager about off-premise catering. To-go trays and party platters available.

  • Private party facilities

    Whether celebrating a special occasion with family and friends or hosting a corporate event, Mill Creek Tavern can accommodate all your special event needs.

  • Private party contact

    Private Event Coordinator: (516) 628-2000

  • Neighbourhood

    Bayville

  • Cross Street

    Pine Park

  • Parking Details

    Private lot & street parking are available

  • Additional

    Banquet, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Cafe, Cocktails, Delivery, Full Bar, Gluten-free Options, Happy Hour, Indoor Fireplace, Non-Smoking, Private Room, Takeout, Vegan, Wheelchair Access, Wine

Popular dishes

What 773 people are saying

Overall ratings and reviews

Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant

4.7
4.7 based on recent ratings
  • 4.6Food
  • 4.8Service
  • 4.5Ambience
  • 4.4Value

NoiseModerate

Sort by

  1. Paul3510

    New York Area

    45 reviews

    vip
    3.0

    45 reviews

    Dined on May 26, 2023

    overall3food3service4ambience4
    We liked the restaurant’s ambience. The staff was attentive. We were a little disappointed in the food. My steak, ordered for medium was a little too rare. Not that big a deal, but my husband’s Lobster Bisque was very disappointing. Would have expected to see some pieces of lobster. I think that they might have just waved a lobster over the pot, LOL. We did tell the hostess this, and she did say she would tell the chef.
  2. JeffK

    New York Area

    14 reviews

    5.0

    14 reviews

    Dined on May 17, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Awesome Birthday gift. Family enjoyed as well. Marinated skirt steak never disappoints. Mac & cheese was delicious. Looking forward to our return.
  3. justme

    New York Area

    37 reviews

    vip
    5.0

    37 reviews

    Dined on May 17, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience4
    The service and food never disappoints. The place is a regular go to for us.
  4. kabob519

    New York Area

    21 reviews

    5.0

    21 reviews

    Dined on May 14, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Jeanne was our waitress and she always takes good care of us. Delicious food and great service - as always👍🏻
  5. deb59

    New York Area

    53 reviews

    vip
    4.0

    53 reviews

    Dined on April 28, 2023

    overall4food4service5ambience4
    Does not disappoint- the pork chop is “to die for”!
  6. Jams1

    New York Area

    10 reviews

    vip
    5.0

    10 reviews

    Dined on April 27, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Our favorite local spot!
  7. kabob519

    New York Area

    21 reviews

    5.0

    21 reviews

    Dined on April 25, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    The usual fine dining that we gave come to expect. Jeanne was our waitress- very friendly and accommodating.
  8. DebraG

    New York Area

    15 reviews

    4.0

    15 reviews

    Dined on April 14, 2023

    overall4food5service5ambience4
    Wonderful as usual. Delicious food, friendly attentive service, a true pleasure.
  9. justme

    New York Area

    37 reviews

    vip
    5.0

    37 reviews

    Dined on March 30, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience4
    A great local stop that never disappoints. This day we had all specials for dinner. A wonderful coconut chicken with a mango salsa and an on-bone veal chop parmesan. Both were wonderful.
  10. OpenTable Diner

    New York Area

    16 reviews

    vip
    5.0

    16 reviews

    Dined on March 19, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    We had a great family dinner at Mill Creek! The pierogis appetizer was delicious ! My salmon,one of the specials was delicious, served with a zucchini pancake - yum The service excellent- i really liked our server! So friendly and helpful with menu choices and considerate of everyones’ needs! Cozy and family friendly vibe! I can’t wait to go back!
  11. OpenTable Diner

    New York Area

    21 reviews

    vip
    5.0

    21 reviews

    Dined on March 18, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Always a great meal and service! A favorite for a good reason
  12. OpenTable Diner

    New York Area

    6 reviews

    5.0

    6 reviews

    Dined on March 17, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    I come 30 minutes to come here from the south shore. I’m always happy with the food and the service is top notch.it’s also a nice spot in the town to walk around. Definitely will be back.
  13. LyndaP

    New York Area

    10 reviews

    5.0

    10 reviews

    Dined on February 25, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Delicious food and welcoming staff and great service
  14. Davesreview

    New York Area

    31 reviews

    vip
    5.0

    31 reviews

    Dined on February 24, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Always great! Food and service are exceptional. Fresh ingredients cooked perfectly.
  15. dkny

    New York Area

    3 reviews

    5.0

    3 reviews

    Dined on February 19, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Mill Creek Tavern is our go-to restaurant! The food is absolutely delicious, the hostesses and waiters are so kind and patient, and the ambience is warm and welcoming! Mill Creek truly feels like the small-town restaurant that you see in the movies, and wish your town had it. We’re lucky because we do!
  16. SK282

    Orlando

    12 reviews

    5.0

    12 reviews

    Dined on February 18, 2023

    overall5food4service5ambience4
    Good food. Attentive, very nice service. Will definitely go back!
  17. RachelG

    New York Area

    2 reviews

    5.0

    2 reviews

    Dined on February 18, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Had a great experience celebrating a birthday!
  18. Jim627

    New York Area

    3 reviews

    5.0

    3 reviews

    Dined on February 14, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Mill Creek is a wonderful neighborhood restaurant, owned by a Bayville resident who makes sure everything is perfect! The atmosphere is friendly, with a great bar area, cozy booths and tables as well. There are 2 rooms, and it is very comfortable. The food is wonderful and well prepared, and there are specials every day! I recommend Mill Creek for a wonderful dining experience!
  19. JeffK

    New York Area

    14 reviews

    5.0

    14 reviews

    Dined on February 14, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Valentine’s Day dinner. What a great place, and not even to charge double on this special day as all the other restaurants do. I enjoyed the sea scallops with shrimp risotto so much that I’m still dreaming about it today. My wife had the salmon that was cooked to perfection. We couldn’t have enjoyed our meal anymore than we did. Topped off with a cappuccino and a fudge brownie sundae. One of our favorite spots to go to. Looking forward to the next time.
  20. JoeS

    New York Area

    1 review

    5.0

    1 review

    Dined on February 14, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Awesome place to eat. Never had a bad meal there. The service is top notch. Shout out to Jean and Vanessa. They are the best
  21. kabob519

    New York Area

    21 reviews

    5.0

    21 reviews

    Dined on February 14, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    We spent a delightful Valentine’s evening- our dinner was excellent and so was the service. Vanessa is a true professional who goes above and beyond to ensure your dining experience is always enjoyable. This is our go to place for all occasions.
  22. MrsHeart

    New York Area

    1 review

    5.0

    1 review

    Dined on February 14, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience3
    Always a great meal. The owners truly cares about his customers and stopped by to see us. It was a special occasion and MCT delivered and made our evening wonderful.
  23. Steven

    New York Area

    10 reviews

    vip
    5.0

    10 reviews

    Dined on February 11, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    We came in from Greenpoint for the evening and we made reservations here. We were surprised about the quality of food. Chicken schnitzel, rock shrimp, and the Cesar salad were our favorites.
  24. RosemarieR

    New York Area

    1 review

    5.0

    1 review

    Dined on January 27, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Was my granddaughter”s birthday. Everything was perfect. Food,service was excellent 👏👏
  25. EricA

    Washington DC

    4 reviews

    vip
    4.0

    4 reviews

    Dined on January 14, 2023

    overall4food4service4ambience4
    Overall, the restaurant was good! Loved the Kung Pao Cauliflower! The Ahi Tuna appetizer needed more chips (which they gave us). The entrees (Shepherds Pie and Ravioli was delicious). We would go back!
  26. SuzyQ

    New York Area

    6 reviews

    5.0

    6 reviews

    Dined on January 13, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience4
    This is one of my favorite places to eat. The menu is varied and I can always find something I like. Friday and Saturday nights are busy and the place is usually packed with locals. I was in the mood for some comfort food this night, and I have to say that the Chicken Schnitzel I had was the most perfectly prepared chicken breast I have ever eaten. In spite of both the bar and dining room being busy, I could still converse with my dining companion because the booths have plexiglass dividers between them.
  27. OpenTable Diner

    New York Area

    1 review

    vip
    5.0

    1 review

    Dined on January 6, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Never a bad experince! Staff! Good (OMG those pork chops!)! A++++
  28. Jayj

    San Francisco

    1 review

    5.0

    1 review

    Dined on January 4, 2023

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Atmosphere was pleasant and cozy. We ordered several courses and they were all properly timed, correct temperature and delicious. From being greeting to leaving the restaurant, the staff was attentive, friendly and very welcoming. Will definitely be back.
  29. Lola

    New York Area

    67 reviews

    vip
    4.0

    67 reviews

    Dined on December 31, 2022

    overall4food4service5ambience3
    A little neighborhood place with decent to excellent food and very good wait staff. Despite it being NYE, everyone made us feel like they were truly happy we were there
  30. RobertaM

    New York Area

    1 review

    5.0

    1 review

    Dined on December 31, 2022

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Awesome evening. Food was excellent. Service was wonderful.
  31. PattiP411

    New York Area

    37 reviews

    vip
    5.0

    37 reviews

    Dined on December 28, 2022

    overall5food5service5ambience4
    Food service drinks all good. Rustic décor always a good meal and service
  32. Maureena

    New York Area

    1 review

    5.0

    1 review

    Dined on December 24, 2022

    overall5food5service4ambience5
    Our server was pleasant and helpful, we just lingered a little too long getting the check. Food was delicious. The place was festively decorated. There was a birthday a few tables down that was very exciting!
  33. danb

    New York Area

    10 reviews

    5.0

    10 reviews

    Dined on December 23, 2022

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Second time I had dinner at Mill Creek Tavern in the past month. It was an even better experience than the last time when I gave 5 stars across the board… food is excellent, service is friendly and accommodating, it was a warm and cozy place to be on a very very cold and freezing night with a nice fire burning in the fireplace…..
  34. Howdeb

    New York Area

    9 reviews

    vip
    5.0

    9 reviews

    Dined on December 22, 2022

    overall5food5service5ambience4
    We probably go once a month for dinner but this last Wed was a first for me trying the bar-b-que special and it was fantastic. I recommend the Mac and cheese side dish.
  35. phillipL

    New York Area

    86 reviews

    vip
    5.0

    86 reviews

    Dined on December 15, 2022

    overall5food5service5ambience4
    Great food great service I would definitely recommend
  36. Alan

    New York Area

    37 reviews

    vip
    5.0

    37 reviews

    Dined on December 11, 2022

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Had the chicken cutlet - was amazing. My wife had the Ahi Tuna and it was excellent.
  37. OpenTable Diner

    New York Area

    1 review

    5.0

    1 review

    Dined on November 19, 2022

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Great staff. Great food!
  38. JohnE

    New York Area

    1 review

    5.0

    1 review

    Dined on November 12, 2022

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Always a great choice. Great food, service and overall experience.
  39. JeffreyM

    Atlantic City

    3 reviews

    5.0

    3 reviews

    Dined on November 9, 2022

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    Good Service good food, been here a few times, always consistently good.
  40. danb

    New York Area

    10 reviews

    5.0

    10 reviews

    Dined on November 8, 2022

    overall5food5service5ambience5
    The menu has many selections. It’s easy to find anything one would be in the mood for with such a vast number of excellent choices….we had the sole oreganata with spinach shrimp mussels on a bed of zucchini pasta in a very light broth… it was fantastic… the wait staff was totally attentive and cordial… its a great relaxed and friendly atmosphere …..it’s easy to go home with a totally satisfied experience at mill creek tavern…

Safety precautions

  • Cleaning & sanitising

    • Surfaces sanitised between seatings
    • Common areas deep-cleaned daily
    • Sanitiser or wipes provided for customers
    • Contactless payment available
  • Screening

    • Sick staff prohibited in the workplace

FAQs

You can order delivery directly from Mill Creek Tavern using the Order Online button. Mill Creek Tavern also offers delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. Mill Creek Tavern also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (516) 628-2000.

Mill Creek Tavern is rated 4.7 stars by 773 OpenTable diners.

Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable.

Make a reservation

2 people

7:00 p.m.


Booked 4 times today
Google Map for Mill Creek Tavern

275 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709

Additional information

  • Cross Street

    Pine Park

  • Neighbourhood

    Bayville

  • Hours of Operation

    Dinner Tue–Sun 4:30 pm–9:00 pm

  • Cuisines

    American, Californian, Contemporary American

  • Dining style

    Casual Elegant

  • Dress Code

    Casual Dress

  • Parking Details

    Private lot & street parking are available

  • Payment Options

    AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa

  • Executive Chef

    Julio Cruz

  • Additional

    Banquet, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Cafe, Cocktails, Delivery, Full Bar, Gluten-free Options, Happy Hour, Indoor Fireplace, Non-Smoking, Private Room, Takeout, Vegan, Wheelchair Access, Wine

  • Phone number

    (516) 628-2000

  • Catering

    Speak to our catering manager about off-premise catering. To-go trays and party platters available.

  • Private party facilities

    Whether celebrating a special occasion with family and friends or hosting a corporate event, Mill Creek Tavern can accommodate all your special event needs.

  • Private party contact

    Private Event Coordinator: (516) 628-2000

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2023 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 500, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
Rentalcars Logo
OpenTable Logo