Mr. Dominic's on Main
Out to dinner w Friends. Started with a couple drinks at the bar and sat for dinner shortly after. I wish I could remember our servers name as she was EXCELLENT. She knew the wine list and the menu well. She was super friendly and made sure we were well taken care of. Food came out quickly and was very tasty. We will be back soon!
The food was excellent as always! There were 7 of us and we all enjoyed our meal. Service was ok, but it was a Friday night and the place was packed! I’ve been here many times already and will continue to go back.
We always enjoy the food ( large menu selection and specials! ) and service. Our waitress ( Lauren) was efficient, upbeat and made the evening that much better!
The food at Mr. Dominic's has always been stellar. I've never had a bad meal or bad service. I've noticed over the years how what once was a very classy/elegant/low key environment has begun to morph to a more hip/less formal environment. While I do appreciate younger generations appreciating wonderful food and wonderful service, I would also think about instituting a dress code as some of the clientele dined in hoodies and did not live up to the caliber of the restaurant. This is typically a favorite go-to spot for family dinners and even more formal occasions but I might think twice about bringing business clients to a spot with young adults, 21-25, who are not necessarily dressed for the environment.
Initial service was excellent, but we had a huge lag between appetizers and dinner. Pasta special was loaded with garlic and too spicy for several of us to finish.
Lasagna and gnocchi where perfect!
Donna is the best server at any Rochester area restaurant!!!!
It was fantastic the food was hot and the sauce was nice as always. I wanted Stuffed Haddock with casino mix but as I found out it is only at the lake. We had Chicken Theresa which was absolutely perfect and Chicken Parm. The wine was also perfect . We also had the Clams Casino and a meatball as appetizers also amazing . We finished with a HUGE piece of Chocolate cake .....
the service was fantastic as requested we asked not to be rushed and they brought out our food as asked . On a night like Valentines Day you want to take your time and enjoy every bite and we did .
This was our first time at the Fairport location 5 of 5 stars
Wonderful restaurant, friendly and helpful stall. Handicapped acceptable. Parking attendants available. Parking lot is adjacent to restaurant. Variety of Foods vegan to meat lovers. Bathrooms are handicapped friendly. Reservations are available online. Wait time is reported axccurately.
As always a fantastic meal, atmosphere, and great customer service!
Food waspretty good. Clams were great. Meatball good. Greens and sausage was not great. Sausage tasted like it was pre cooked a few days ago. Not fresh. Shrimp scampi ok.
We had a party of 4 and all of us rated our meals as 5 stars out of 5. The initial service by our waitress was slow. We had a 6:15pm reservation and were seated quickly at 6:15pm. We received our water and bread basket within minutes of being seated. The only negative was that our waitress took maybe 8-10 minutes to come by and take our initial drink orders. After that she was very good. I would definitely go back.
Great food and service.
Always love Mr. Dominic’s
Service was quick but felt rushed.
It was the day after Christmas- they were out of sparking water and different meals etc. the waitress had great energy but our orders weren’t right and it took forever to get all parts of our orders. Disappointed, but we’ve been before with better service so we will continue to be returning customers.
Great food and service!
Josh was an excellent waiter, quite attentive but not over-reaching. Martini was quite good, the blue cheese olive was an excellent perk. Scallops were perfection, seafood platter was delicious and dipping sauces were a plus. Braciole was also excellent. The only drawback was my guests request for no garlic (due to an allergy to garlic); the marinara sauce did contain some despite her request from its inclusion she did have a reaction. It was the only blemish on an otherwise perfect evening dinner.
Josh was such a professional. He was accommodating and made our experience on Christmas Eve above expectations.
We've never had a bad meal at Mr. Dominics. Tonight was no exception and, being a Sunday evening, the restaurant was not terribly busy so we have attentive, friendly service.
Just go there.. its amazing. We had the best service and portions were huge.
Food was aweful! Swordfish was over cooked, salmon not blacken as ordered, green beans raw-barely warm. Manicotti was good, pork chop ok. Mixed green salad was fine, Caesar salad wilted and mostly croutons. Not going back!
Very accommodating from the moment we arrived till we left. Manager, barmaid, waiters/waitresses very friendly. Felt like home. Been there a number of times, one of our favorite restaurants!
I am hoping that they just had a bad night. But the one Bartender was terrible. The bar wasn't even busy and he couldn't be bothered to even pour a glass of wine. Finally the other bartender helped us out. We sat down right away the service was sub par. They were shorthanded and a 7:30 pm reservation we didn't get our food till after 9pm. And unfortunately we have had amazing meals but this was not one of them. For the price i will go to Black and Blue before going here again.
Service was excellent, food was GREAT, and the ambience is really, really nice and relaxing. I would recommend it to anyone !
Great food, excellent service and an all around pleasant experience.
We had a gift card. We enjoyed our meals but thought the waiter could have been a little more attentive. We will be back.
Nice meal with friends. Chicken Joseph always excellent. Great server . Nice atmosphere
Our server Donna was wonderful. She was very attentive and personable. However, it did get very loud as the night went on. We had quite a boisterous table next to us. The food was great and substantial proportions. We all went home with leftovers.
Disappointed with our experience as it felt like everything has gone downhill.
The food was extremely poor quality. We even sent back a plate. No one checked up on us or anything to ensure the new meal brought out was sufficient. Definitely won’t be back. The quality has gone way down lately.
Great night amazing food and perfect pricing. Second time there with hopes of many more visits
We had a pleasant experience. Our seating was prompt, waitress was courteous and attentive. The food was very delicious and served promptly. The prices are a bit more than most restaurants but we expected that. Overall, a great experience.
I wish I could remember our waitresses name, because she was fantastic. We definitely recommend the Artichokes French, it was sooooo good !
We had a wonderful time! The Green Lantern is where my husband and I first met, so it is very special.
The food was good, but what was outstanding was the service given. The waitress was friendly, helpful and actually made us feel so at home. The busboy was considerate also. I wish I knew their names. She recently returned from California. I can't say enough about her !
We will certainly return and recommend it to our friends.
Great server at a table in the bar area. Enjoyed a great bottle of J Lohr cab with friends . Food was solid chicken Joseph was on point and well prepared.
Great service, great food and great portions for an affordable price. Good wine list for everyday drinking options. Beautiful historic home with huge ceilings and magnificent wood work, but very loud. Boisterous groups thoroughly enjoying a Friday night dinner. This isn't the place for a quiet romantic meal, but it was a perfect selection for family. Wish we'd had time to enjoy the outside patio and music.
Went on a Friday night. The place was pretty busy - even had a really large event going in a side room. Despite that, the service was spot on. Very attentive waitress and other staff as well. We were never left needing to flag anyone down.
Chicken and veal parmesan and surf and turf ordered at the table with a nice bottle of wine. The food was fantastic!
I really recommend trying this place if you're ever looking for a nice Italian meal!
I was looking for an authentic locally owned Italian restaurant. I definitely found it here!! The food was delicious and exactly what I was looking for. Our server, Donna, was great and I appreciated her patience with my questions. I wish we had a restaurant like this where I live.
Mr. Dominic's on Main is rated 4.4 stars by 73 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.