Nick & Stef’s Steakhouse - New York
- Surfaces sanitised between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitised menu provided
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Staff temperature check required
- Proof of vaccination required to dine indoors
Rib Eye Steak
bone on 20oz*
Very crowded. Jammed way too many tables in small area. For the prices they charge, could have removed a few tables and given people breathing room. Close to a venue we went to and convenient. Not sure I’d go back given other choices.
Everything was excellent, would highly recommend
Great service, great food. However, The tables were very close together which increased the noise quite a bit. Prices were high for the food and drinks. But pretty much on point with other steak houses in the area. Overall, a Very nice dining experience.
Rachael was amazing! Knowledgeable, took interest in our occasion, timely with our food, attentive to our needs. Wonderful job! Great experience.
apps and drinks at the bar pre NY rangers game
We had an amazing experience at Nick and Stefs. One of the members in our party forgot their vax card but the hostess and general manager made extraordinary accommodations to move our reservation to a later time so we could still have our meal together even thought the restaurant was very busy. The evening was a special occasion so I can not thank the restaurant team enough. Service was outstanding, the food delicious. An amazing evening and we will be back for sure.
Steak was over cooked
Dessert was cold and should have been warmed
Price was high for disappointing food
Has been better
Good and service were awesome
Great service, waitstaff was very professional and knowledgeable about the menu and nightly specials.
Always enjoy going before the Ranger games. Food is consistently good
Was very excited to try out this restaurant on a girls night out. Immediately upon sitting down the waiter spilled an ENTIRE glass of water all over my friend. Apologized one time and nothing was done about it. No manager came over to speak to us. He didn’t offer to buy us our first round of drinks or take anything off the check. Good was mediocre at beast. Dessert was absolutely stale. Overall just not a good experience especially for how expensive it was. Would not recommend.
Alycia provided superb and efficient service with the supplementation of amazing ancillary staff! Fresh mozzarella and tomatoes disappointed but porterhouse for two instantly made us forget! Great experience and definitely would return!
Beautiful steak dinner before the country show @MSG (Luke Combs). Will def be back!
Thank you so much for your feedback. We are so glad you were pleased and look forward to seeing you again soon!
Restaurant was not open at my reservation time. I called them and left a message.
My companion and I have dined frequently and plentifully. This experience by far was one of our greatest. The food was delicious, the service was superb, and the location was spot on. Although a bit pricey, we enjoy fine dining and the food was worth it. The service made our visit even more worthwhile. We will definitely go back.
Thank you so much for your fantastic review! We love getting positive feedback and I will certainly share your sentiments with the rest of our team We look forward to seeing you again soon! Best Regards, Alex Balbuena Asst. GM @ N&S
Kathy, our hostess was outstanding with info for the night!
We had not been back to your restaurant since March of 2020 since Covid shut down the city!! Steve was our waiter and he was great telling us about specials and other available amenities. Overall, it was the best experience coming back to MSG for a NYR game that turned out to be spectacular game winning in the end!!
We have missed you NYC and will be back again soon!!
Great service and attention by the entire staff. The steaks were fantastic.
Thank you so much for the positive feedback. We look forward to seeing you again.
Nick & Stef's was a fantastic place to eat just before a Rangers game. Visiting my daughter, traveling from Las Vegas, we were looking for a memorable place for dinner, and this was the one! Ribeye was to die for, cooked to perfection. Clams were fresh and served cold, albeit a tad small, but that's a personal preference. Calamari, lightly fried, hot, and flavorful! Service was great, Steven was a seasoned pro and a full complement of bus people rounded out the staff. Topped it off with mango sorbet and an apertif. Big bonus is we just go through a secret door near the entrance and viola! we're in MSG and heading for our seats to the game.
Thank you so much for the feedback. We are so glad you were pleased and look forward to future visits.
My petite filet wasn’t good. Creamed spinach was great. My wife had the chicken abs loved it. My son had the 12 oz filet and loved it
Very good service, food excellent. Very happy with our meal.
Great business lunch. This is the place for lunch if you are around Penn station.
spice Tuna TarTar was great. The Short rib was perfect! Great wine by the glass. Profession al service. Our Server was Michelle a true professional!
Thank you so much for the feedback. We are so glad you enjoyed and yes, Michelle is a rockstar!
Good food..great service
Nick and Stefs are back in a big way. Everything was perfect for a sensational dinner
Very over priced even by NYC standards. Food was decent but not worth the cost.
Dear Jordodette, Thanks so much for your honest feedback. We look to guests like you to make us even better. Best, Alex Balbuena Asst. GM @ N&S
My son and I had a wonderful dinner on Saturday night before The Dave Matthews Band concert at MSG, The food and service was fantastic! I would highly recommend!
Service was excellent, the food was exceptional, would highly recommend!
Dear RandyE Thank you so much for the fantastic review! We love getting positive feedback and I will certainly share your sentiments with the rest of our team. Hope you'll be back soon. Best, Alex Balbuena Assistant GM @ N&S
We had the pleasure of enjoying this restaurant before a game at Madison Square Gardens. The food was delicious, service was on point, ambiance was beautiful. We were all still talking about dinner the next day. If you get the chance definitely add this to your list!
We are so glad you enjoyed your visit with us! We love getting positive feedback and I will be sure to share your sentiments with the rest of the team. Hope you'll be back soon! Best, Alex Balbuena Asst GM @ N&S
Great food and great service. Fast but not rushed. Perfect for a game or concert at the garden.
Very nice place. Consistently good
Thank you so much for your positive review. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Fabulous food, fabulous service & fabulous chef Danny!
Thank you so much for your fantastic review! We love getting positive feedback and I will certainly share your compliments with the rest of the team. Hope you'll be back soon! Best, Alex Balbuena Asst GM @ N&S
Excellent service and food but really noisy. Was there pre-Billy Joel, post-Covid. Been there before where pleasant coversation was possible.
Unbelievably fast meal service. Staff is incredibly pleasant.
Dear PinkUStink, So glad you came to see us before the concert. Your positive review is appreciated and we hope to see you again soon! Best, Alex Balbuena Asst GM @ N&S
We had dinner before the show at MSG. Service was very good. Filet was good, not great. Croutons in salad were stale, fries cold (had to send back) bread and butter both cold. Manager came over to apologize offered a round of drinks but when the bill came, no comp’d drinks. Overall disappointed and wouldn’t recommend.
Dear Gigi We're so sorry to hear your experience with us wasn't perfect! We take honest comments from our guests very seriously, and are always looking for ways to improve. We hope to see you again. Best, Alex Balbuena Asst GM @N&S
I had a caesar salad and the shrimp scampi over garlic sauteed spinach which was delicious.
Dear MarkG So glad to hear you enjoyed your visit with us. We look forward to seeing you again soon! Best, Alex Balbuena Asst. GM@ N&S
The crab cake special with delicious. The roast chicken with truffle fries was good although the fries were a little too salty for my taste. They were crispy and hot. he cinnamon sugar beignets were SO good.
The service was AMAZING!
Dear sophiac, Thanks so much for your fantastic review! We hope you'll be back to see us soon. Best, Alex Balbuena Asst GM@ N&S
Always a pleasure and a pleasant experience…
Dear Azzurri, Thank you so much for your kind review. We love getting positive feedback and look forward to seeing you again soon! Best Regards, Alex Balbuena Asst. Manager Nick&Stefs
Great place to go before a MSG event for its convenience. Wouldn’t go otherwise
It’s very convenient to Pennsylvania station but extremely noisy and the ambiance is just okay
The steak was unevenly cooked and was sinewy in certain areas. I didn’t finish the 10 ounces
The service was wonderful!
Warm welcome, prompt but considerate service, with meals themselves great pleasures for all in our party.
A really lovely dinner pre-concert. Food was excellent! And if you are going to the Garden, they will help you enter via a VIP entrance.
Dear Rachel. Thank you very much for your amazing review, we are happy to hear that we excided your dinning expectations and looking forward to see you again soon. Best Alex Balbuena Assistant GM at NS
Nick & Stef’s Steakhouse - New York offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 563-4444.
Nick & Stef’s Steakhouse - New York is rated 4.5 stars by 2450 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.