North Plank Road Tavern
Delicious food and excellent service
This restaurant isn't the best at anything. Food was served cold. Mushroom soup lacked flavor and was not creamy. Pork special was just OK. Short Ribs were good. The Chocolate Cake was very heavy, tasted old.
The server was very nice, but the manager/owner was a little strange. We will not be back.
Great Service….Excellent Food ….Great Portions ..Great Price
Last night was our first time at the tavern and we definitely will be back !!
I had read some previous reviews, and they were right on point . From the outside you can easily miss it! The inside is beautiful and clean !
The food was fresh and and absolutely delicious !!!! Outdoes many of the other restaurants by far !!!!
The staff were very friendly. We loved our waitress. The atmosphere was cozy, but a bit quiet. We had the pork shoulder and the house smoked ribs. We liked both dishes and would recommend. Overall a great experience.
Birthday dinner. Great folks, delicious cod special and chicken dinners
Owner was very cranky after we asked him to sit outside, he replied that he could not accommodate it. Another staff member mentioned the outside and that she would check o. The outside since a table had just left. Owner came to us and said another two some was waiting 45 minutes fir that table. Food was good but not worth someone being rude to us.
The host was terrific, the food was good and the outdoor terrace was very pleasant. This is a cool place.
Excellent food and great waitstaff. We had an very early dinner so we were the only ones dining and it was quiet. The noise-level can get higher when filled.
Great food and service
It was really an excellent culinary experience. The beet salad was really fresh and crisp, and the sea scallops really tasty
The food is always fresh, locally sourced and delicious. It’s definitely one of our favorite places to eat in Newburgh!
Our first time here and we will be back. We highly recommend both the salmon and the scallops. The service was excellent and we were made to feel like we were regular patrons.
This is a slice of heaven with a “come as you are” attitude. Great food, staff and history!
Good food and service in a historical building. Very friendly owner.
Best dinner! So glad we were able to dine in as they re-opened! Service and food was excellent!
Stumbled upon this on accident and was blown away by how beautiful it was and how incredible the food was. Can’t wait to go back! I also appreciated how much history was shared with us— really an incredible experience!
I have wanted to eat at this restaurant for some time and so glad we finally made it. Will be returning. Love the atmosphere and the owners were very nice. Good very good as well.
A great little gem
Delicious food, great service. Loved hearing about the history of the restaurant. Will definitely return.
Excellent farm to table food. Dishes all prepared and presented exceptionally well. By far the best restaurant in the Newburgh area. Worth travelling for. A foodie's delight. Will be back.
Everything we had was fresh and delicious-right down to the homemade whipped cream on our chocolate mousse.
Wonderful experience, I enjoyed the recommendations from owner on trying a apple cider cocktail which was wonderful. Food was excellent. Our server was knowledgeable and attentive. Wonderful meal, we will be back soon. Maybe for that “Hanger Steak” lol
As always, North Plank Tavern delivered excellent food with stellar service!
Have not been back here to eat for a while, but was glad we did. A wonderfully historic property with great food and service. Our drinks were delicious, the wine list is varied and accessible, and the food was expertly prepared. Highly recommend this place if you're looking for an alternative to paying too much for mediocre food at some of the fancier places down on the river in Newburgh. This place has genuine ambiance, and a great menu that has a good mix of items without trying to be everything to everyone.
adorable historic building.Felt like I was eating in grandma's dining room. service was great. Food was great. octopus was cooked perfectly. Mushroom raviolis were delish!!
New Years Eve. Price fix menu. They ran out of what would be the most popular main course (filet mignon), and dessert (chocolate mousse cake) by 8 PM. Place was over-crowded and under-staffed. My wife and I eat out at their patio in the summer all the time, and the food and service are always good. They had to know by the number of reservations that they booked, how crowded the place would be, but they were totally ill-equipped to handle it that night.
Awesome food! Wait staff was very kind, but a bit forgetful - it look a long time for him to bring us bread and when we asked for more, it never came. But all the food we ordered were outstanding.
Food was great
Service even better
Will definitely be returning
I must admit we came twice during HVRW and I wish we could afford to come more often. Maybe for a special occasion but otherwise in the spring during HVRW again. I cannot impress upon you how wonderful the food and service was. I had been to several restaurants during that two week period and I must say your restaurant outdid all the others by far. Looking forward to coming back again.
North Plank Road Tavern offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (845) 562-5031.
North Plank Road Tavern is rated 4.4 stars by 31 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.