The Colden Mill Restaurant
Had a great time at dinner but my sweet potato fries were awful. Would definitely go back though.
If you're looking for a relaxing atmosphere after a gorgeous short drive thru the hills, stop here. We were en route to the West Falls Center for the Arts for a concert, but our waitress was helpful getting us in and out within about an hour.
It was nice having a top-shelf dinner is such a Currier and Ives setting. The duck was unbelievable, and crab cakes are always a must as an appie. The owner Mike was behind the bar attentively watching over. I'll definitely go back---and recommend it to anyone looking for a reasonably priced, memorable meal.
Used a groupon but still very expensive. 2 Steak dinners which were lukewarm. Plates came out different times. Service was good but did not think the menu was great. It is a not a fine dining ambiance in my opinion - lovely, cozy but not expensive dinners.
Used your app to reserve a table and had a terrible placement near entrance where people kept walking through us. The food was tasty, but little range of choices- very high caloric items. The service was poor and we felt like we were just an add on. We won’t be returning.
Very good meal.
Our dinner was delicious. I had a pork chop special and my husband had the steak. We walked out of there very impressed with the chef. We will definitely be back.
The food was really quite good and enjoyed the ambiance immensely. Always a beautiful spot for a nice meal.
Been here many times and they always stay true. Love this place!
The ambiance was great. Service was friendly and good. The menu could offer more choices. Parking was somewhat of a problem. It's on a corner that seemed to have a lot of traffic when we were trying to back out of the parking space. I would recommend it to a friend. The ride out on an autumn day was beautiful. We are very glad we tried this restaurant.
Rustic, quiet atmosphere. The food was delicious and the service wonderful. Highly recommend
Food was excellent. We have come to this restaurant three times, and the food has been amazing every time.
First of all, we like the drive up. The 3 different dinner dishes that were served, all were super, well prepared and very delicious, no complaints. The dinner rolls were great, could have enter a few more. Finally, the waitress was super and funny with a sense of humor. We all had a great time.
Colden Mill is our go-to night out. Food is always outstanding. Matt is an artist in the kitchen. And Chuck makes the BEST Cosmopolitan there is!
We went for s wonderful birthday meal. The food was delicious. The restaurant did not read my reservation notes. We did not receive the table I requested ( although they did move us once I told them I did not like our table) no candle in the dessert, didn’t hand the check to me. I’ll go back, but with the understanding they don’t care about my simple, advance requests.
Outdoor seating by the creek with plants all around us, under a tree, with great food and drink made for a lovely night out!
Very nice night on the outside deck. Food as always was very good as was the service. Be back soon.
Had a wonderful time, the food with some of the best I have ever had and the service and atmosphere made you feel so welcome
We were able to sit out on the patio, which overlooks the river. It was like sitting in a tree house! It was enchanting! The shrimp Mac and cheese was divine! The tuna dish was not as good, but the flavours were wonderful. Service was excellent and all the staff were quite friendly. We used a Groupon and we were welcomed as any other patron and asked to come again. I have rarely had that level of enthusiasm with using a Groupon. This is a great place and I recommend it highly!
My wife’s children special was very good. Food is always of high quality at a very good value. Another nice night.
Great food, great service, worth the drive from Buffalo, brought back memories from our younger days skiing at Kissing Bridge.....
Great meal, but not cheap. You do get what you pay for.
We made our reservation for the deck, and it really was perfect! The tables are nicely spaced apart, and it's very cozy surrounded by trees with the view of the creek and the sound of a small waterfall in the background.
And the food- fabulous!! The four of us all had something different and it was all excellent! Cooked superbly, large portions,
phenomenal taste! I guess my biggest complaint is the roasted veggies portion was a bit skimpy.
We will be back there, and soon!
Perfect evening. Amazing ambiance. The food was excellent. Our server Teresa was wonderful. Will definitely go back and will recommend to friends.
Chuck, bartender and owner, was great at explaining and recommending a variety of options on the menu. The appetizers, entrees and desserts were phenomenal. We will definitely be making the drive out there again in the future.
Overall wonderful experience, we will be back!
The food was amazing and our server was fantastic
Food was decent. I had the tenderloin pasta which was tasty, my companion had the filet mignon which was slightly overdone. The chorizo pepper was good, and different, and the grilled romaine salad was great. Dessert was the sorbet which was very flavorful and refreshing. Sat on the deck and it was beautiful. Waitress was friendly and attentive, if inexperienced. Overall a good experience. I expect we'll be back.
Always a wonderful experience dining at Colden Mill. Friendly and efficient staff and food is very good.
Nice relaxing atmosphere. Food was very enjoyable and the service was great.
Weather was finally nice enough to sit outside. Deck atmosphere is very nice. Dinner was very good. I had the bacon wrapped meatloaf which was outstanding. My wife’s tenderloin pasta was also very good. All and all a very nice evening.
Excellent evening. Wonderful menu and food. Will be returning.
The Colden Mill is the "go-to" place for my husband and me. This visit we took some family along, and they loved it as much as we do!
Colden Mill is outstanding! We enjoyed a beautiful, relaxing night out with our family. Started with drinks at the bar and continued to our table where we were greeted by our always sweet waitress. Our meals were absolutely delicious! The chef is amazing and his attention to detail is superior.
I love the Colden Mill's food and ambiance. Typically we receive superior service. However, this trip was a disappointment in that regard. The server forgot about a beer my husband ordered. It sat on the bar for 20 minutes before it was served, and my husband had to remind her. We were not even close to finished eating, with forks in our mouths, and she asked if we were ready for dessert. A few minutes later, while still visibly eating, she asked if we wanted dessert. When we said no, she asked if we were ready for our check. She was either in our face or completely out of the picture. It was a strange visit to say the least. We will return to the Colden Mill, but request a different server in the future.
Filet was amazing!
we have been to the Colden Mill a few times and we are never disappointed. The food is fantastic, the service is outstanding & we love it!
Absolutely fabulous!! Go there now!! Food was delicious, atmosphere very cozy and the entire staff was so friendly. Chrissy our waitress, was outstanding and always there with a smile.
Our waitress was absolutely amazing and the chef always on point. The food, service and atmosphere was perfect!
We absolutely enjoyed the Easter brunch! Great environment, good selection and fabulous service
Chuck always mixes a great drink, and Matt makes amazing dinners! The atmosphere is so comfortable and the servers are all top-notch! One of our favorite places.