Diners' Choice: Best Overall restaurants in Caribbean

OpenTable

Updated September 05, 2024

Looking for the best overall restaurants in Caribbean? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favourite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Epicuro

5.0

5 (98)

$50 and over

Global, International

Condado

About the restaurant

True to its name, the Chef’s Table feels gloriously indulgent, inviting lucky diners on a hedonistic journey encapsulating Antonio Pérez’s life in Puerto Rico and his culinary career across South America, Europe, and Asia. The setting feels intimate and wildly special, with just 12 seats surrounding the open kitchen, complemented by a lounge area for a welcome cava before dinner or a post-tasting menu digestif. The themed-driven five-course menu changes monthly along with its wine pairing.
This is not merely another dining experience; it’s an intimate journey through the heart and soul of a Puerto Rican cook and his global culinary influences. Do not reserve a number of diners higher than desired, in our kitchen everything is prepared for all confirmed reservations, as such, we will regard it as a no show who has failed to comply with the reservation. If you wish to cancel your reservation, please give us at least three day’s notice. Thank you for your kindness and understanding.

Top review

OpenTable Diner

Dined on Jul 5, 2024

Amazing experience. 10/10 duck press was superb. Everything was exceptional

Discover more

Experience

Chef's Table (Wednesday)

Experience

Chef's Table (Thursday)

Experience

Chef's Table (Friday)

Rasa

5.0

5 (9)

$50 and over

Caribbean

Grand Cayman

About the restaurant

Engage in an immersive culinary journey through international cultures, regional recipes, and adventurous creations, centered around a singular specialty concept and rotating every few months. With an exclusive front row seat in the heart of our buzzing, world-class exhibition kitchen, you’ll delight in vivid culinary creations coming to life before your eyes. Experience a single world culture’s cuisine in classic, sophisticated depth, with a few original twists, through a uniquely curated tasting menu from our highly decorated chefs, every one selected for their extraordinary talents and gastronomic vision. A bespoke beverage and wine pairing program intertwines with each current cultural menu concept. Our intimate space fosters connection and stimulating conversation with both chefs and guests for an experience you won’t soon duplicate or forget.

Top review

Ze Manuel Correia

Dined 5 days ago

Working through the courses at Rasa, we had quickly realized that this was going to be one of the best dining experiences of our lives. The curated menu was incredibly well thought out and every element on every dish was an absolute treat. We elected the premium wine pairing, and the sommelier Brenton had an incredible story for each pairing. Cannot recommend highly enough. Thanks for the amazing experience, and we'll be back for the next rendition of the menu!

The Rocks

5.0

5 (168)

$31 to $50

Caribbean

Nevis

About the restaurant

Discover lively Caribbean cuisine paired with global flair at our restaurant 'The Rocks'. Fresh fish and lobster come from local fishermen; tropical fruits and vegetables from neighboring growers. Breakfast, lunch, and dinner are served alfresco on our dining decks overlooking the sea, or within intimate garden settings. Under stone vaulted ceilings, our bar serves signature cocktails such as the Mount St. Helena and Golden Rock’s renown Rum Punch.

Top review

Amr89vip

Dined on Aug 4, 2024

The food was excellent, the best we tried on Nevis during our 9 day stay. The setting is secluded and beautiful, and has a great indoor-outdoor setup. The staff were also kind and very helpful as well!

Asia de Lima

4.9

4.9 (50)

$30 and under

Italian

Condado

About the restaurant

We have a varied menu of pizza and pasta with Asian and Peruvian flavors. We also have traditional flavors and cocktails in a family atmosphere.

Top review

Brandon

Dined on Aug 5, 2024

The food and the drinks were amazing. Nice vibe inside. Best suited for small intimate gatherings.

NOVA

4.8

4.8 (16)

$31 to $50

Mediterranean

West Bay

About the restaurant

An idyllic & inspired dining experience in the Cayman Islands. NOVA is a beachfront gem nestled on the north shore of West Bay. Mediterranean-Japanese fusion cuisine matched with innovative drinks;
NOVA’s open-air backdrop sets the stage for laid-back elegance. A breezy lunch poolside followed by cocktails on the beach. Or a sunset dinner with photo-worthy views. NOVA brings friends & family together in a unique waterfront setting.

Top review

DiscD

Dined on Jul 15, 2024

Nova was lovely location - right on the shore - very quiet (it was a Monday night). Very friendly staff - good excellent - our son particularly enjoyed the nova burger - said one of best he’s tasted on island! Praise indeed!

Aria

4.9

4.9 (103)

$31 to $50

Mediterranean

Grand Harbour

About the restaurant

At Aria, we pride ourselves on delivering superior quality throughout every aspect of the dining experience, every time. Expect the freshest, highest quality ingredients, knowledgeable staff, exceptional service, and a beautifully designed, modern space.

We’re the leading innovator in Mediterranean cuisine on the island, with chefs hand-picked from across the Mediterranean. Our menu honors the history and heritage of the food, while still managing to be fresh and modern.

And as part of the Agua Hospitality Group our guests can expect the same superior quality and experience they have come to enjoy at our other establishments.

For event inquiries, please visit: https://www.ariacayman.ky/events

Top review

Daminivip

Dined on Sep 1, 2024

fantastic food, New York City level! The chicken skewers and tagliatelle Bolognese were great

Discover more

Experience

Express Lunch

Experience

Dine Around The Mediterranean

Experience

Date Night

El Corcho

4.9

4.9 (18)

$31 to $50

Spanish

San Juan

About the restaurant

Looking for a culinary experience full of exquisite flavors? Welcome to El Corcho, where we seamlessly blend the rich culinary traditions of Spain and Puerto Rico into an unforgettable dining experience. Indulge in our carefully crafted fusion dishes, curated selection of wines, and exclusive ambiance.

Top review

Rafa

Dined on Jun 5, 2024

As always the experience was outstanding. The Chef Carlos was very attentive as well as his service staff. Very good place for a private and comfortable business lunch or get together with friends.

MacDuffs - Norman's Cay

4.9

4.9 (64)

$31 to $50

Caribbean

Exumas

About the restaurant

MacDuff’s Restaurant is a quaint Bahamian outpost that has been around for quite some time. It was originally known as a landmark for boat men to meet over a burger on the island. Daily Items include tropical flare like, our fresh caught grouper sandwich, sandwiches, salads and our famous cheese burger from paradise. With a pleasant, mellow vibe fitting of island life, the rustic chic appeal and exposed wood beams are designed to give patrons a relaxed island experience while enjoying the delights of American and Bahamian cuisine. We look forward to welcoming you. Have a beautiful day.

WE ARE NOW CASHLESS!

Please feel free to call us at: +1 (242) 805-2235 or email us at: reservations@macduffscottages.com

If you wish to make a reservation for a time after 7pm please call or email for availability.
Our opening hours change with the seasons.

Top review

AlexC

Dined on Aug 13, 2024

Just had an amazing dinner at McDuff’s on Normans Cay in the Exumas, Bahamas, and it was everything we could’ve hoped for! The vibe there is so chill, perfect for a relaxing evening after a day out on the water. For dinner, I went with the Caribbean Bowl, and let me tell you, it was a flavor-packed delight! 🍲 The bowl came loaded with grilled chicken, savory rice and beans, fresh corn, tangy pickled onions, crunchy cabbage slaw, and creamy avocado slices. Every bite was a perfect mix of textures and flavors, totally hit the spot! I also couldn’t resist getting a side of fried plantains—crispy on the outside, soft and sweet on the inside. They were the perfect complement to the meal! 🍌 To wash it all down, I opted for a virgin mango daiquiri. 🥭🍹 It was super refreshing with that perfect balance of sweet and tangy, and just look at that vibrant color! Topped with a cherry and a slice of orange, it was the ideal tropical drink to pair with the meal. If you’re ever at Normans Cay in the Exumas, McDuff’s is a must-visit. The food is awesome, the drinks are on point, and the setting is just what you need for a laid-back island experience.

Wilo Eatery & Bar

4.9

4.9 (550)

$31 to $50

International

Guaynabo

About the restaurant

The new Wilo Benet culinary experience is here and it's cooking! After 28 years of running Pikayo, get ready for the evolution of our great flavors and services at our new location, Wilo Eatery & Bar!

Top review

Jose

Dined on Aug 31, 2024

We were with a friend for a special occasion, she loved it. Tried the flan for the first time, BEST EVER! Our server Mario, out of this world. Best night ever Would most definitely come again

Boutique Speakeasy

4.8

4.8 (20)

$30 and under

Speakeasy

Oranjestad

About the restaurant

A place where unique drinks weave secret melodies, and create an unforgettable experience.

Top review

Theo

Dined 4 days ago

Boutique never fails! Service is outstanding just like the drinks and music. Highly recommend the Local Chick cocktail. Will be back again for sure