The food and service was very good, the drinks we ordered were a little high ($8.00) for Bourbon and Coke, and the Perch, for 6 small filets @ $26.00 was not worth it. Should have had the Steak Sammy,
This place is wonderful! Definitely worth the drive!!!
It’s always amazing
The prime rib was delicious, and a lot of different wines to choose from. It was Friday and crowded, but no line when we arrived with reservations for 6pm. We left around 7pm and by then some people were waiting for a table. This place is a gem and I highly recommend it. I plan to eat there again.
Exceeded our expectations
I drove quite a ways to try the resturant. I was most disappointed with my entree, prime rib. It was not as tender as I would have expected from a pricey resturant. Aside from my entree, overall the food was very good. I was able to try my friends entrees, and the salmon and sammy steak were exceptional. The caesars salad exceeded my expectations and the fries were outstandanding .
This restaurant hasn't changed in 20 years, nor should it...excellent food, friendly staff, and good strong drinks! Keep up the good work and don't change a thing :)
Excellent as always thanks for a great meal and service
Still love the Filet Mignon, can't go wrong with it
Food was delicious and our server was right on top of everything.
Terrific all around!
The service and food were very awesome. We will definitely be back again.
Everyone had a veal dish and they were all excellent. I have been going to Sibley"s for many years. Love their menu.
We took some friends who had not been here before. We had steaks and shrimp that were delicious! They were happy they finally stopped in and will surely come again.
Lovely lunch with my BFFs. It was great to be seated in the same booth my friend’s father sits in with his longtime friends. Very special and sentimental. Steak Sammy, can’t beat it.
Went to celebrate husbands Birthday. Food is awesome. Great service. Excellent place to eat
Enjoyed the evening with family celebrating a birthday. The food was very good, service exceptional and all made the evening very enjoyable. Enjoy Sibley Gardens when it is just 2 of us or a get together with others. Our reservation was as requested, timely and in the location we asked for.
Me and my Wife love the food and its always a great time everyone that works at the restaurant has a great smile and cheerful manor about them thank you for a great dinner and great time
My husband and I were celebrating a late Valentines dinner and we’ve never been to Sibley Gardens before. I found it online and I have heard great things about this restaurant. We were so pleased with the entire experience. The service, the food, the ambiance was all fantastic! We will definitely be back. We are foodies and this restaurant is on the top of our list to eat.
Each time I go, I am impressed with the food, service and value. I highly recommend you go to Sibley Gardens and see for yourself.
great waitress and good food, they could do a little more for birthdays.
This place is a downriver staple, the service was great even on a busy Valentine’s Day. The food was prepared perfectly, my wife had the lobster which was a very large portion, and I had the salmon also a very good sized portion. Moreover, both of our entree’s were delicious and served at the correct time. Cannot say enough good things, you must try this place!
My wife and I absolutely love the filet mignon every time we go. Had a table but recommend getting a booth if you go.
Atmosphere, service, food and company was great..
Specials are exceptionaly good, as well as menu items...
Fabulous Who are a wonderful night out we love coming to this restaurant it’s one of our favorites I always bring friends and family here when they’re in town .
Onion rings..! Onion rings..! Onion rings..!
Server was great. Truly great. Steak was good as were drinks.
Wonderful food and wait staff will definitely be back
Great food and service. Portion sizes are great. Beer selection is pretty bad, but other than that, it is a great place for a nice dinner.
First visit here. Overall, the food was very good. Server could have used more training as he was recently promoted from being a busser. The antipasto should be skipped. Scant meats and cheeses. Veal Parm, Steak Sammy and other dishes were very good.
Always love dining here. When on a date next time, may ask for the bar area as it actually seemed quieter than the main dining room.
Food was fantastic. Bloody Mary wasn't very good. We'll definitely go back, but stick with beer next time. Waitress was very pleasant.
Not my first time at Sibley Gardens and it won't be my last. The Steak Sammy is my go-to dish, and it always is perfection. I love the asparagus side; always cooked perfectly too. We split the goat cheese Napolean dish, and that was excellent as well.
I tried the Bourbon Lemonade drink on their special drinks menu, and it was good.
The only downside was our creme brulee was completely overcooked. The custard was very dry, which is not normal for this restaurant.
I absolutely recommend Sibley Gardens, and make sure you get the Steak Sammy.
Quality food and service. Never disappointed.
Very good restaurant, food is hot and very good, service was also very good. I would highly recommend this restaurant. Our waiter was attentive all evening.
We had a wonderful time, I had a customer come in from out of town and he was amazed by the service and by the food.
It was a Friday night so the restraunt was very noisy but great service and food. We love going there for special occasions.
This was our first visit to Sibley Gardens and the food was delicious. The crab cakes were outstanding and did not smell fishy like most restaurant do. My husband ordered the pork chops and could only finish one of the two chops. Top of my favorites list.
I have a salt problem and Kelly steered me on what to order and the chef did my grouper with no salt and a baked potato naked and salad balsamic only. All three of us we're pleased with everything. Keep up the good work.